What's JetPunk's criteria for statehood, anyways?

Submitted by FreeStater on January 25, 2026
Maybe it made more sense back when it was finalized in 2011, but nowadays, JetPunk's criteria for what is and isn't a country seems ill-defined.

I have no qualms regarding the 193 UN members + Vatican City, but it seems odd to include Kosovo and Taiwan, which only a slight majority and a minuscule minority of countries recognize, respectively—but then exclude other quasi-states such as Abkhazia and Somaliland.

Palestine is another issue. Over 80% of UN member states recognize it, and while its government is definitely in a weird spot, Hamas and Fatah control a non-negligible amount of territory between them. Western Sahara is similar, where the SADR controls about a fifth of the territory they claim and are recognized by forty-four UN member states. According to the United Nations and the African Union, it's still Spain's problem!

There's also the Cook Islands and Niue. They have their own governments, diplomatic relations, and currencies (used in tandem with the NZD). However, New Zealand can be called in to handle diplomacy and defense on request, citizens of the two are automatically NZ citizens, and the head of state is the monarch of NZ by default. Despite the UN recognizing them as "non-member states," New Zealand is adverse to calling them sovereign under the current situation.

My recommendation: add Abkhazia, Somaliland, South Ossetia, and Western Sahara.

What are everyone's thoughts?

13 Comments
+7
Level 72
Jan 25, 2026
If we recognized every partially recognized area of the world, I feel like there would be more problems than solutions. Keeping it limited to what we have now seems like the best approach from Dan.
+5
Level 81
Jan 25, 2026
I agree, but every "country" I discussed is recognized by at least one UN member state. The only well-known quasi-state that isn't is Transnistria.

Taiwan, the least-recognized country on JetPunk's list, is only recognized by twelve others. Measly compared to some excluded countries.

+4
Level 72
Jan 25, 2026
I think it boils down to what the U.S. as a whole officially recognizes and respects. We recognize Taiwan to support their global independence movement away from China. We recognize Kosovo as a breakaway state from Serbia because Kosovo has very strong admiration for us. I agree there could be some changes to the JetPunk world map, but I see it as trivial, and I'm assuming Dan does as well.
+3
Level 75
Jan 26, 2026
The US recognizes Niue and the Cook Islands as separate countries.
+2
Level 61
Jan 25, 2026
Definitely not Abkhazia and South Ossetia as they only have 5 recognizers and not Somaliland as it only has one
+1
Level 40
Jan 26, 2026
However, Somaliland does actually exert more control over their territory than say Western Sahara or maybe even Palestine, not certain though
+2
Level 71
Jan 26, 2026
I think they probably included the more stable places (it helps because quizzes won't be updated as often)
+1
Level 63
Jan 26, 2026
international recognition, and control of territory?
+5
Level ∞
Jan 26, 2026
Control of territory and bias towards not making capricious changes.

The UN could vote to say that gravity doesn't exist and we all therefore live in atmosphere, bobbing around like clouds. It doesn't make it true.

+1
Level 63
Jan 26, 2026
what did i say unerudite
+5
Level 62
Jan 26, 2026
Taiwan is an independent country, so it should stay. The only reason it has limited recognition is that everybody has to kowtow to China, so I would ignore the "number of countries who recognise it".
+2
Level 61
Jan 26, 2026
100% agreed. Recognition really comes down to relations with the countries.
+3
Level 57
Jan 26, 2026
I think the criteria for statehood is the whim of the all powerful Quizmaster