| Record | Season | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 73 home runs | 2001 | Barry Bonds | 91%
|
| 4,256 hits | - | Pete Rose | 86%
|
| 2,632 consecutive games played | - | Cal Ripken | 85%
|
| 5,714 strikeouts (pitcher) | - | Nolan Ryan | 80%
|
| 130 stolen bases | 1982 | Rickey Henderson | 80%
|
| .690 slugging % | - | Babe Ruth | 77%
|
| 652 saves | - | Mariano Rivera | 76%
|
| 56 game hitting streak | 1941 | Joe DiMaggio | 73%
|
| 511 wins | - | Cy Young | 72%
|
| 262 hits | 2004 | Ichiro Suzuki | 66%
|
| .367 batting average | - | Ty Cobb | 66%
|
| 7 Cy Young awards | - | Roger Clemens | 58%
|
| 10 World Series championships (player) | - | Yogi Berra | 57%
|
| 2,297 RBI's | - | Hank Aaron | 55%
|
| 13 Golden Gloves (shortstop) | - | Ozzie Smith | 55%
|
| 81 pickoffs (catcher) | - | Ivan Rodriguez | 54%
|
| .482 on-base % | - | Ted Williams | 54%
|
| .394 batting average (since 1950) | 1994 | Tony Gwynn | 48%
|
| 1.12 ERA (starting pitcher since 1950) | 1968 | Bob Gibson | 47%
|
| 16 Golden Gloves (third base) | - | Brooks Robinson | 47%
|
| 355 wins (since 1950) | - | Greg Maddux | 44%
|
| Oldest pitcher to win a game (49 years) | - | Jamie Moyer | 32%
|
| 59 consecutive scoreless innings pitched | 1988 | Orel Hershiser | 31%
|
| 191 RBIs | 1930 | Hack Wilson | 28%
|
| 31 wins (since 1950) | 1968 | Denny McLain | 20%
|
| 223 strikeouts (batter) | 2009 | Mark Reynolds | 16%
|
| 23 triples (since 1950) | 2007 | Curtis Granderson | 11%
|