Citypopulation.de lists Wuhan as larger than Washington, and its numbers are if anything conservative (most figures elsewhere seem to say 11 million - they've been quoted in the media a lot recently for some reason...)
Just wondering, why Shenzhen, Foshan, Dongguan etc. are still considered with Guangzhou for urban area, while Chongqing which is today supposed to be the biggest urban agglomeration in the world (at least according to some Chinese sources) is still listed with few million inhabitants?
The "Chongqing is the largest city proper in the world" claim is based on the population of Chongqing Municipality, which covers an area of 82,300 sq km - that's about the size of Austria, and larger than Ireland or Sri Lanka. It's twice the size of Switzerland. For the Americans, it's around the size of South Carolina. And it certainly isn't all city - some of the Municipality's Districts and Counties actually have lower population density than the Chinese national average. The actual urban area of Chongqing consists of 9 districts that make up less than 7% of the Municipality's area and about a third of the Municipality's population. Don't get me wrong - it's a big city, just not THAT big, and certainly not close to being China's largest, let alone the world's. Essentially, Chongqing Municipality is a province in all but name.
These definitions are always a bit loose, but as a rule of thumb, JetPunk (along with many other sources) defines any place in China as part of East Asia, even though, culturally speaking, Urumqi is closer to the Central Asian countries than to most of China.
This is the same definition used by the UN, as you can see on their website:
https://unstats.un.org/unsd/methodology/m49/
The quiz does not need an update, but JetPunk users should be aware of the conventions being followed here. For example, JetPunk does not consider Palestine a country, even though most countries in the world recognize it as an autonomous, though occupied, state, and even the UN has granted it independent observer status.
I am not complaining, just pointing out JetPunk's choices, and how its up to the user to understand the sites conventions.
India has 2 cities there, so was Japan and Canada with 2 each too. So what's your point including india in your comment? Ofc you wouldnt add japan and canada🙄
I am pretty sure that you are wrong about Edmonton having 1.3 million people. As far as I know, Canada only has 3 cities with over 1 million; Toronto, Montreal, and Calgary (Where I live.)
Ho Chi Minh City has more people than Hyderabad now. Is it not included for a reason (because it's also called Saigon) or was it just missed during the update?
I don't like calling Saigon "Ho Chi Minh". he was a bad guy and should not have this great city named after him. I'm glad JetPunk accepts Saigon for HCMC.
Thought I was getting them all. Then I hit Z. Chinese cities are all way too similar to remember, and so many. I tried Zhenzhen, Zhenzhao, Zhaozhang, Zhenzhou...
Claiming Urumqi is in East Asia misled me. Even if it's part of China, I don't think it's a suitable definition when one wants to define the location of the city.
The population of Fuzhou is a typo surely? 4.55 million would make a lot more sense than 45.5 especially considering that Fujian (the province Fuzhou is in) apparently has a population of 38.56 million and also contains Xiamen.
The 21.8m comes from citypopulation.de which uses "Metro Population" instead of "City Population". This gives a better idea of how many people are in a city in a given day versus how many people live in a specific government drawn line that a lot of times doesn't match the city at all. For the best example I have found of this look at the map of Los Angeles metro area versus the actual city limits. It's ridiculous.
Given this, the NYC metro area actually includes parts of NJ, CT, and even a couple counties in PA. Which leads to it actually having a larger population than NY state.
It's so interesting how Canada has 2 cities on here, despite several other cities on this list having a metro area more populous than the entirety of Canada!
We may have the 2 least populated on the list, but still!
The pinyin romanization doesn't have the letter V in it so that could explain part of it I guess (seeing how many Chinese cities there are on this list...)
Xiamen 2016 estimate; 3,920,000
Xi'an 2016 estimate; 8,832,100
This is the same definition used by the UN, as you can see on their website:
https://unstats.un.org/unsd/methodology/m49/
The quiz does not need an update, but JetPunk users should be aware of the conventions being followed here. For example, JetPunk does not consider Palestine a country, even though most countries in the world recognize it as an autonomous, though occupied, state, and even the UN has granted it independent observer status.
I am not complaining, just pointing out JetPunk's choices, and how its up to the user to understand the sites conventions.
Perhaps I missed it because 'zh' in standard Mandarin is pronounced similarly to 'j' in English.
I don't like calling Saigon "Ho Chi Minh". he was a bad guy and should not have this great city named after him. I'm glad JetPunk accepts Saigon for HCMC.
Not in East Asia like the majority.
Given this, the NYC metro area actually includes parts of NJ, CT, and even a couple counties in PA. Which leads to it actually having a larger population than NY state.
China 9
Canada 2
India 2
Japan 2
Brazil 1
Egypt 1
France 1
Indonesia 1
Myanmar 1
Nigeria 1
Pakistan 1
Philippines 1
Thailand 1
Turkey 1
United States 1
We may have the 2 least populated on the list, but still!