The Island is actually a copy of an earlier low-budget movie called Parts: The Clonus Horror, which has the exact same plot, but also stars Dick Sergeant and Peter Graves. Fun fact!
It appears there as the highest grossing Science Fiction/Dystopia film. One of the few on this list that is about a true Dystopia, in the traditional sense. And I've correctly filed Star Wars under fantasy where it belongs, too. Not science fiction. Pretty happy with how it turned out overall.
Genre is the sort of thing that is not always clearly defined. Films may exist in multiple genres, or genres may overlap, or there could be sub-genres and meta-genres, etc, depending on how you choose to classify things.
If we're using "Space Opera" as a genre, then Star Wars is the most iconic film that would be included in that genre, along with the television shows that inspired it such as Buck Rogers and Flash Gordon. If we're using the genres of "science fiction" and "fastasy," though, with traditional definitions of each, then Star Wars is definitely fantasy. It's confusing, though, as "Space Opera" is usually described as a sub-genre of Science Fiction, though one that veers toward the fantastical. A simple definition of fantasy is a story that is not based in the real world... throw in some old desert wizards, taverns full of fantastical creatures, warriors with magic swords moving things with their minds without a plausible scientific explanation.. fantasy!
There is totally such a thing as fantasy based in the real world, or at least a version of the real world. Urban fantasy covers a lot of that. Historical fantasy is a thing too - like historical fiction but with fantasy elements such as magic and/or fantastical creatures in it.
I'd also guess that a lot of people are familiar with the title, but other than that only know it for the phrase "Big Brother is watching you." If that was the clue I bet the percentage would be higher. Even so, it's currently at 75% with only five titles scoring higher.
Interesting quiz.. I expected "A Scanner Darkly" and "THX 1138" to be there, too, but you've got the most important. Mhm, maybe also "The Time-Machine"...
Many of these are not truly "Dystopian." A Dystopian future is one where things on the surface *seem* idyllic but there is something terribly wrong... Logan's Run is a good example. As is Minority Report. Or else it is the failed attempt to achieve utopia, as in 1984. But many of these are really just post-apocalyptic movies (Planet of the Apes, Matrix, etc.) or just straight-up sci-fi like Robocop.
hm.. ok.. guess some of these kind of fit definition 2 on wikipedia, though I always heard definition 1 used, which matches what I was saying. I think def. 2 is probably just a corruption of the meaning of the word popularized by people who didn't understand definition 1. But... language is dynamic.
There's an interesting article about the difference between an anti-utopia (which is what you're describing) and a dystopia. If I can find it, I'll post it, but the scholar dude basically says that an anti-utopia, like any anti-genre, is a parody of the genre it opposes. An anti-utopia parodies utopian ideals by considerably wonking them up. A dystopia, on the other hand, is what the Wikipedia article states--an undesirable or terrifying community. But it's with or without utopian ideals. Scholar dude also notes that a dystopia is the bad things in an author's community taken to their extreme logical end. Hence dys = bad while anti = against. An anti-utopia is always a dystopia because it includes bad, messed-up communities, but a dystopia is not always an anti-utopia. I hope that wasn't too pedantic. It was probably too pedantic.
but that still goes against the first (and in my opinion better) definition given on the Wikipedia page. A utopian society that has been corrupted. Usually portrayed in fiction as a place where everything seems great (or just in some ways better) at first glance, until the protagonist uncovers what's really going on.
So.. like... in Robocop, for example. The future society depicted in that film was *never* utopian. There was never any corruption of a utopian world. It was always just shitty.
The original Stepford Wives is one that's difficult to place. The male characters thought they created a utopia, while the females who still had their wits about them thought they were living in horror. It always seemed like a dystopian film to me, but it's usually filed under horror. Some might even see it as fantasy-horror if there is such a thing, and then they turned the remake into a comedy. (But I still think the 1975 version would be a good addition here.)
A dystopia can also be a society that is made to be utopian for some people or from a certain point of view but can be dysfunctional or horrifying from an alternate point of view or upon a closer look, so I think the Stepford Wives fits pretty well.
I was shocked by Mad Max missing but understand the dystopian thing....So where is The Handmaid's Tale, based on the book by Margaret Atwood? THAT is a seemingly idyllic world where women are taken into homes to serve as babymakers....something our Congressional would endorse. I never even heard of a couple of these.... It's funny there are so few things that women write or that have female leads, compared to males---even when there are very famous ones among our half of the population, lists are just 10 or 20% female authors, or lead characters in stories.... (I think it's why Hunger Games, Twilight stuff is so huge--there is a high demand for books and movies with female leads or equal participants, but so little is published lor publicized, when people find some they gobble it up, even when it's really poorly written or shallow.)
I'd never seen the movie or heard of the plot, either, but saw it referenced all the time on The Daily Show, Simpsons, Futurama etc. I was able to piece together just from those that it was about a food product that someone didn't realize was made of people.
Anyway, after seeing it referenced so many times I decided to check it out, obvious cultural cornerstone that it was. Not a bad little picture. Not great, but interesting premise. Good high-concept classic sci-fi...
I saw it in a theater when it was first released and I remember how we were all totally freaked out by the ending. (Not as much as we had been freaked out by Deliverance, though. There were some "memorable" movies made in the 1970s.)
Unfortunate that it seems to be happening sooner than the film predicted. After looking over the comments shocked that no one has thrown out V for Vendetta.
Oh come on... you really think that we would elect a president who had no real qualifications or good ideas but appeared on a professional wrestling program? That's just a little far-fetched...
The plot description used to describe "Logan's Run" also describes the plot of "Wild in the Streets", a '60's movie starring Christopher Jones and Shelly Winters.
I only missed Hunger Games and Divergent, which after looking them both up and finding out they're both children's books released after I was an adult, I don't feel too bad about it. Feels like an odd choice to include those anyway.
Highest Grossing Films by Genre quiz.
It appears there as the highest grossing Science Fiction/Dystopia film. One of the few on this list that is about a true Dystopia, in the traditional sense. And I've correctly filed Star Wars under fantasy where it belongs, too. Not science fiction. Pretty happy with how it turned out overall.
If we're using "Space Opera" as a genre, then Star Wars is the most iconic film that would be included in that genre, along with the television shows that inspired it such as Buck Rogers and Flash Gordon. If we're using the genres of "science fiction" and "fastasy," though, with traditional definitions of each, then Star Wars is definitely fantasy. It's confusing, though, as "Space Opera" is usually described as a sub-genre of Science Fiction, though one that veers toward the fantastical. A simple definition of fantasy is a story that is not based in the real world... throw in some old desert wizards, taverns full of fantastical creatures, warriors with magic swords moving things with their minds without a plausible scientific explanation.. fantasy!
Anyway, after seeing it referenced so many times I decided to check it out, obvious cultural cornerstone that it was. Not a bad little picture. Not great, but interesting premise. Good high-concept classic sci-fi...
also i guessed Mad Max and learned that it takes place in the Outback