| Clue | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 4th largest island and home to lemurs | Madagascar | 87%
|
| World's largest island (not including continents) | Greenland | 85%
|
| Central NYC island | Manhattan | 85%
|
| Island nation divided between Greeks and Turks | Cyprus | 80%
|
| Legendary island that sank into the Atlantic | Atlantis | 77%
|
| The UK and Argentina fought a war over them | Falkland Islands | 77%
|
| Islands visited by Darwin | Galapagos | 77%
|
| Southernmost Australian state | Tasmania | 77%
|
| Island of Brooklyn and Queens | Long Island | 69%
|
| Ancestral home of the Corleone family | Sicily | 68%
|
| Honolulu's island | Oahu | 65%
|
| Where Napoleon was born | Corsica | 64%
|
| Island shared by Haiti and the Dominican Republic | Hispaniola | 62%
|
| Tokyo's island | Honshu | 59%
|
| Spanish party island. From Miami to ... | Ibiza | 59%
|
| Last of the Florida Keys. Hemingway lived there | Key West | 51%
|
| Largest Canadian island | Baffin | 48%
|
| Able was I, ere I saw it | Elba | 46%
|
| 3rd largest island | Borneo | 45%
|
| Where he died | St. Helena | 41%
|
| King Kong's island | Skull Island | 35%
|
| 2nd largest island | New Guinea | 34%
|
| Former whaling town - home to Captain Ahab | Nantucket | 25%
|
| Island from "Jaws" | Amity Island | 19%
|