| Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Superhero who got bit by a radioactive spider | Spiderman | 100%
|
| Nunchuck-wielding ninja turtle | Michelangelo | 81%
|
| Central Perk waitress who married Ross twice | Rachel Green | 80%
|
| Grouchy monster of "Sesame Street" who lives in a garbage can | Oscar the Grouch | 68%
|
| 1920s bootlegger who had great parties at his Long Island mansion | Jay Gatsby | 61%
|
| Telepathic X-Men leader | Charles Xavier | 56%
|
| Jerry Seinfeld's weird next-door neighbor | Cosmo Kramer | 55%
|
| Sicilian gangster who became "The Godfather" | Vito Corleone | 51%
|
| Handsome ad exec of "Mad Men" | Don Draper | 49%
|
| New York cop who defeated Euro-terrorists in "Die Hard" | John McClane | 47%
|
| "Lovable" icon of 1950s TV married to Cuban band leader | Lucy Ricardo | 46%
|
| Male model who started a center for kids who can't read good | Derek Zoolander | 45%
|
| Cosmo-sipping sex columnist who buys expensive shoes | Carrie Bradshaw | 42%
|
| "Catcher in the Rye" narrator | Holden Caulfield | 37%
|
| Gluttonous green ghost who haunted the Sedgewick Hotel before getting busted | Slimer | 36%
|
| Delivery boy who was frozen and woke up in the year 3000 | Philip J. Fry | 35%
|
| African-American couple who moved on up to the East Side | George and Louise Jefferson | 31%
|
| He's the cop that won't back down when there's trouble all around. Shut your mouth! | John Shaft | 26%
|
| Head writer for "The Girlie Show" | Liz Lemon | 14%
|
| Little girl of children's books who lives on the tippy-top floor of the Plaza Hotel | Eloise | 13%
|