| WAR | Years | Team | Position | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 34.0 | 1926–1928 | Yankees | OF | Babe Ruth | 99%
|
| 32.9 | 2001–2003 | Giants | OF | Barry Bonds | 90%
|
| 32.0 | 1955–1957 | Yankees | OF | Mickey Mantle | 83%
|
| 28.2 | 2000–2002 | Diamondbacks | P | Randy Johnson | 83%
|
| 28.0 | 2012–2014 | Angels | OF | Mike Trout | 82%
|
| 28.7 | 2022–2024 | Angels / Dodgers | P / DH | Shohei Ohtani | 80%
|
| 32.8 | 1963–1965 | Giants | OF | Willie Mays | 80%
|
| 27.5 | 2000–2002 | Mariners / Rangers | SS | Alex Rodriguez | 78%
|
| 28.8 | 1927–1929 | Yankees | 1B | Lou Gehrig | 78%
|
| 29.3 | 1946–1948 | Red Sox | OF | Ted Williams | 76%
|
| 27.6 | 2007–2009 | Cardinals | 1B | Albert Pujols | 74%
|
| 27.0 | 1961–1963 | Braves | OF | Hank Aaron | 74%
|
| 28.5 | 1998–2000 | Red Sox | P | Pedro Martinez | 72%
|
| 33.3 | 1968–1970 | Cardinals | P | Bob Gibson | 66%
|
| 28.2 | 1996–1998 | Red Sox / Blue Jays | P | Roger Clemens | 64%
|
| 27.7 | 1948–1950 | Cardinals | OF | Stan Musial | 62%
|
| 28.4 | 1966–1968 | Red Sox | OF | Carl Yastrzemski | 58%
|
| 27.4 | 1958–1960 | Cubs | SS | Ernie Banks | 58%
|
| 27.5 | 1971–1973 | Mets | P | Tom Seaver | 57%
|
| 29.2 | 1974–1976 | Reds | 2B | Joe Morgan | 50%
|
| 28.7 | 1932–1934 | A's | 1B | Jimmie Foxx | 40%
|
| 30.4 | 1920–1922 | Cardinals | 2B | Rogers Hornsby | 38%
|
| 29.8 | 1944–1946 | Tigers | P | Hal Newhouser | 19%
|
| 28.5 | 1935–1937 | Red Sox | P | Lefty Grove | 16%
|
| 27.7 | 1972–1974 | Indians | P | Gaylord Perry | 15%
|
| 28.8 | 1971–1973 | White Sox | P | Wilbur Wood | 12%
|