| Creature | Type | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Hedwig | Owl | 99%
|
| Dobby | House-Elf | 98%
|
| Nagini | Snake | 96%
|
| Moaning Myrtle | Ghost | 94%
|
| Scabbers | Rat | 93%
|
| Aragog | Acromantula | 92%
|
| Remus Lupin | Werewolf | 92%
|
| Crookshanks | Cat / Kneazle | 90%
|
| Fawkes | Phoenix | 85%
|
| Trevor | Toad | 80%
|
| Norbert(a) | Dragon | 78%
|
| Firenze | Centaur | 70%
|
| Grawp | Giant | 70%
|
| Buckbeak | Hippogriff | 70%
|
| Griphook | Goblin | 66%
|
| Arnold | Pygmy Puff | 25%
|
| Tenebrus | Thestral | 16%
|