| Nickname | Lifespan | Real Name | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honest Abe | 1809–1865 | Abraham Lincoln | 94%
|
| Ike | 1890–1969 | Dwight Eisenhower | 84%
|
| Tricky Dick | 1913–1994 | Richard Nixon | 79%
|
| Scarface | 1899–1947 | Al Capone | 66%
|
| The Bambino | 1895–1948 | George Herman Ruth | 66%
|
| Notorious R.B.G. | 1933–2020 | Ruth Bader Ginsburg | 66%
|
| The Teflon President | 1911–2004 | Ronald Reagan | 64%
|
| Hanoi Jane | 1937– | Jane Fonda | 60%
|
| Satchmo | 1901–1971 | Louis Armstrong | 55%
|
| The Godfather of Soul | 1933–2006 | James Brown | 53%
|
| Old Hickory | 1767–1845 | Andrew Jackson | 50%
|
| The Wizard of Menlo Park | 1847–1931 | Thomas Edison | 48%
|
| Wild Bill | 1837–1876 | James Hickok | 43%
|
| Old Blood and Guts | 1885–1945 | George S. Patton | 42%
|
| Stormin' Norman | 1934–2012 | Norman Schwarzkopf | 39%
|
| Buffalo Bill | 1846–1917 | William Cody | 38%
|
| Lucky Lindy | 1902–1974 | Charles Lindbergh | 37%
|
| The Chairman of the Board | 1915–1998 | Frank Sinatra | 36%
|
| Blackbeard | 1680–1718 | Edward Teach | 33%
|
| Tippecanoe | 1773–1841 | William Henry Harrison | 31%
|