| # | Clue | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The ring-bearer | Frodo | 99%
|
| 3 | Grey wizard | Gandalf | 99%
|
| 2 | Adoptive uncle of #1 | Bilbo | 97%
|
| 6 | Best friend of #1 | Samwise | 96%
|
| 9 | Rightful heir of Gondor | Aragorn | 92%
|
| 10 | Fellowship member (elf) | Legolas | 92%
|
| 5 | Dark Lord of Mordor | Sauron | 92%
|
| 8 | Cousin and companion of #1 | Pippin | 90%
|
| 11 | Fellowship member (dwarf) | Gimli | 88%
|
| 14 | Owner of the ring before #2 | Gollum | 88%
|
| 16 | Evil white wizard | Saruman | 88%
|
| 7 | Cousin and companion of #1 | Merry | 85%
|
| 12 | Fellowship member (man) | Boromir | 83%
|
| 15 | Former name of #14 | Sméagol | 79%
|
| 13 | Younger brother of #12 | Faramir | 75%
|
| 17 | Lord of Rivendell | Elrond | 69%
|
| 18 | Female co-ruler of Lothlórien | Galadriel | 68%
|
| 21 | Leader of the ents | Treebeard | 66%
|
| 20 | Demon who #3 battles in Moria | Durin's Bane | 65%
|
| 22 | Daughter of #17; love interest of #9 | Arwen | 61%
|
| 4 | Horse of #3 | Shadowfax | 61%
|
| 23 | Giant spider who attacks #1 | Shelob | 51%
|
| 24 | Mysterious woodsman - the oldest being in Middle Earth | Tom Bombadil | 49%
|
| 19 | Male co-ruler of Lothlórien | Celeborn | 31%
|