| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Most home runs (762) | Barry Bonds | 77%
|
| Most career no hitters (7) | Nolan Ryan | 65%
|
| Most hits (4,256) | Pete Rose | 64%
|
| Tallest player in the Hall of Fame (6'10") | Randy Johnson | 64%
|
| Fastest pitch recorded in a game (105.8 mph) | Aroldis Chapman | 62%
|
| Only player with 50 home runs and 50 steals in one season | Shohei Ohtani | 58%
|
| Most hits in the postseason (200) | Derek Jeter | 56%
|
| Most hits in a season (262) | Ichiro Suzuki | 51%
|
| Most wins by a pitcher in a season (60) | Old Hoss Radbourn | 51%
|
| Most home runs by a switch hitter (536) | Mickey Mantle | 50%
|
| Only player with 30+ home runs in first 10 seasons | Albert Pujols | 49%
|
| Oldest player to hit his first home run (42) | Bartolo Colón | 47%
|
| Most home runs as a leadoff hitter (81) | Rickey Henderson | 47%
|
| Most putouts by an outfielder (7,095) | Willy Mays | 43%
|
| Most games played with ZERO playoff appearances (2,528) | Ernie Banks | 41%
|
| Most Gold Glove awards (18) | Greg Maddux | 39%
|
| Youngest to play in an All-Star game (19 years old) | Dwight Gooden | 37%
|
| Most times hit by pitch (285) | Craig Biggio | 36%
|
| Most steals of home (54) | Ty Cobb | 30%
|
| Most at-bats in a season (716) | Jimmy Rollins | 23%
|