| Team | # | Years | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Braves | 21 | 1955–1975 | Hank Aaron | 91%
|
| Orioles | 19 | 1983–2001 | Cal Ripken | 83%
|
| Giants | 20 | 1954–1972 | Willie Mays | 81%
|
| Yankees | 16 | 1952–1968 | Mickey Mantle | 80%
|
| Angels | 11 | 2012–2023 | Mike Trout | 80%
|
| Mariners | 10 | 1990–1999 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | 78%
|
| Dodgers | 11 | 2011–2025 | Clayton Kershaw | 77%
|
| Padres | 15 | 1984–1999 | Tony Gwynn | 75%
|
| Cardinals | 21 | 1943–1963 | Stan Musial | 73%
|
| Royals | 13 | 1976–1988 | George Brett | 70%
|
| Mariners | 10 | 2001–2010 | Ichiro Suzuki | 69%
|
| Astros | 9 | 2011–2024 | José Altuve | 69%
|
| Pirates | 12 | 1960–1972 | Roberto Clemente | 69%
|
| Phillies | 12 | 1974–1989 | Mike Schmidt | 67%
|
| Reds | 14 | 1968–1983 | Johnny Bench | 65%
|
| Red Sox | 18 | 1963–1983 | Carl Yastrzemski | 63%
|
| Rangers | 10 | 1992–2001 | Ivan Rodriguez | 63%
|
| Cubs | 11 | 1955–1969 | Ernie Banks | 59%
|
| Athletics | 9 | 1987–1997 | Mark McGwire | 58%
|
| Marlins | 4 | 2012–2017 | Giancarlo Stanton | 56%
|
| Brewers | 5 | 2008–2012 | Ryan Braun | 54%
|
| Rockies | 5 | 2000–2004 | Todd Helton | 53%
|
| Mets | 9 | 1967–1977 | Tom Seaver | 52%
|
| Tigers | 15 | 1955–1974 | Al Kaline | 49%
|
| Nationals/Expos | 7 | 1975–1984 | Gary Carter | 49%
|
| Diamondbacks | 6 | 2013–2018 | Paul Goldschmidt | 47%
|
| Rockies | 5 | 2015–2019 | Nolan Arenado | 44%
|
| Brewers | 5 | 1980–1992 | Paul Molitor | 43%
|
| Twins | 12 | 1967–1978 | Rod Carew | 41%
|
| Marlins | 4 | 2004–2007 | Miguel Cabrera | 40%
|
| Guardians/Indians | 8 | 1938–1950 | Bob Feller | 35%
|
| Rays | 4 | 2010–2014 | David Price | 31%
|
| Rays | 4 | 2004–2010 | Carl Crawford | 24%
|
| Nationals/Expos | 7 | 1981–1987 | Tim Raines | 24%
|
| Blue Jays | 7 | 1980–1990 | Dave Stieb | 22%
|
| White Sox | 12 | 1951–1963 | Nellie Fox | 21%
|
| Brewers | 5 | 1979–1985 | Cecil Cooper | 13%
|
| Guardians/Indians | 8 | 1940–1948 | Lou Boudreau | 12%
|