| Description | Creature | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Horse with a horn on its forehead | Unicorn | 98%
|
| Half woman, half fish | Mermaid | 96%
|
| Bird that rises from its own ashes | Phoenix | 87%
|
| Human who becomes a wolf-like beast under the full moon | Werewolf | 86%
|
| Arabic spirit that might appear from a magic lamp | Genie | 84%
|
| One-eyed giant | Cyclops | 81%
|
| Half man, half horse | Centaur | 78%
|
| Huge, stupid creature that might live under a bridge | Troll | 77%
|
| Abominable snowman | Yeti | 74%
|
| Tiny, mischievous, gold-hording Irish spirit | Leprechaun | 73%
|
| Head of a bull, body of a man | Minotaur | 68%
|
| Gigantic octopus-like sea monster | Kraken | 66%
|
| Three-headed dog that guards Hades | Cerberus | 56%
|
| Many-headed water serpent | Hydra | 55%
|
| Irish spirit with a piercing wail | Banshee | 49%
|
| Body of a lion, head and wings of an eagle | Griffin | 49%
|
| Pacific Northwest name for bigfoot | Sasquatch | 44%
|
| Latin American animal that drinks the blood of livestock | Chupacabra | 43%
|
| What Medusa was | Gorgon | 42%
|
| Half man, half goat with a perpetual erection | Satyr | 39%
|
| Ugly, bird-winged woman | Harpy | 38%
|
| Rooster / serpent hybrid that can kill with a glance | Basilisk | 34%
|