| Description | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Pirate and blacksmith team up to rescue a girl from cursed undead pirates | Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl | 96%
|
| Girl is transported to a strange land after she follows a rabbit down a hole | Alice in Wonderland | 93%
|
| Kooky outsider has shears for hands | Edward Scissorhands | 92%
|
| Barber shop customers end up in meat pies | Sweeney Todd | 69%
|
| Chameleon must solve the case of the missing water in an Old West town | Rango | 59%
|
| Only Ichabod Crane can save townspeople from the Headless Horseman | Sleepy Hollow | 55%
|
| Masked man and Native American fight for justice in the Old West | The Lone Ranger | 54%
|
| Woman shakes up a French town by opening a chocolate shop during Lent | Chocolat | 52%
|
| Burned ghost kills teenagers in their sleep | A Nightmare on Elm Street | 45%
|
| Gonzo journalist and his friend visit Nevada and do many strange drugs | Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas | 36%
|
| Drug dealer becomes America's main cocaine supplier in the 1970s | Blow | 32%
|
| The true story of the worst director of all time | Ed Wood | 26%
|
| Gentlemanly bank robber John Dillinger becomes America's most wanted outlaw | Public Enemies | 26%
|
| Undercover officer infiltrates the mob over the course of several years | Donnie Brasco | 24%
|
| Group of soldiers in Vietnam commit atrocities and fratricide | Platoon | 24%
|
| The true story of Irish-American gangster Whitey Bulger | Black Mass | 23%
|
| Mystery writer is accused of plagiarism by a strange and potentially violent man | Secret Window | 20%
|