| Example of character portrayed | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Uncle Muscles | Weird Al Yankovic | 100%
|
| (Self) Puppeteer, performs songs like 'I'm in love with an insect woman' | David Liebe Hart | 92%
|
| Dr. Steve Brule, amateur doctor | John C. Reilly | 92%
|
| (Self) Wordplay/poorly done impressions comedian | James Quall | 90%
|
| Hosts 'Forting with Will' | Will Forte | 88%
|
| (Self) Host of Dunn & Dunngeons | Richard Dunn | 82%
|
| Mediates conflict stemming from Tim killing Eric's rascal | Bob Odenkirk | 78%
|
| Celery Man, Oyster, Tane and self | Paul Rudd | 76%
|
| Tairy Greene, of Little Dancing Man, etc | Zach Galifianakis | 76%
|
| Actor in 'Pizza Boy' (PSA on saying no to sex) | David Cross | 71%
|
| Endorses WaitMaite, handsome according to Eric | Jeff Goldblum | 65%
|
| Kitty Cat Man | Michael Cera | 59%
|
| Donald Mahanahan, of the Original Child Clown Outlet | Will Ferrell | 59%
|
| Sings the songs of Casey Tatum on infomercial | Josh Groban | 57%
|
| Hosts 'Cleaning up after your cat' | Maria Bamford | 57%
|
| Sings 'Do you really have to pee in a girl's mouth to make babies?' | Rainn Wilson | 57%
|
| J Q's best friend at sailing (college) | Jonah Hill | 55%
|
| Guest on Dunn & Dunngeons | Dave Navarro | 49%
|
| Sings a song about his favorite drink which he hasn't had since he was an infant | Patton Oswalt | 49%
|
| At first, hates Tim and Eric's idea to collaborate/change last name to Stillhur | Ben Stiller | 47%
|
| Endorses the Cinco Phone | Ed Begley Jr | 47%
|
| Hosts 'Focus on Comedy' (Wants to know what Tim and Eric are smoking) | Michael Ian Black | 45%
|
| Survives a a car accident, but is then shrunken to a tiny size | Ted Danson | 45%
|
| KJ Nutt, hosts 'Hobby Holes' | Fred Armisen | 43%
|
| Eric's gift to Tim (a comedy genius to work with) | Robin Williams | 41%
|
| Endorses the Napple | Alan Thicke | 35%
|
| Plays aforementioned comedian in "The J__ Q__ Story" | Bill Hader | 35%
|
| Plays Eric in Spaghett film | Brian Posehn | 35%
|
| The Dark Man | Marilyn Manson | 33%
|
| Watches Tim and Eric's Tennis Showdown with his SNL colleague | Andy Samberg | 29%
|
| The moon (tells Tim and Eric that they're doing great) | Paul Reubens | 29%
|
| Director of Crystal Shyps | AD Miles | 25%
|
| Best man who helps out a groom with the Diarrheaphragm | Jack McBrayer | 25%
|
| Host of Tragg's Trough, feeds his guests blendarized food mix with Brown Slop | Fred Willard | 20%
|
| Eric's Tennis Showdown Double | Jemaine Clement | 20%
|
| Endorses Man Nip | Patrick Duffy | 20%
|
| Tim's Tennis Showdown Double | Brett McKenzie | 14%
|
| Detective who finds Casey's Bones | Wendell Pierce | 4%
|