| Role | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Peter Warne | Clark Gable | 97%
|
| Fletcher Christian | Clark Gable | 97%
|
| Rhett Butler | Clark Gable | 97%
|
| Scarlett O'Hara | Vivien Leigh | 96%
|
| Ellen Andrews | Claudette Colbert | 84%
|
| Melanie Hamilton | Olivia de Havilland | 81%
|
| Mammy | Hattie McDaniel | 77%
|
| Grusinskaya | Greta Garbo | 73%
|
| Ashley Wilkes | Leslie Howard | 69%
|
| Capt. Bligh | Charles Laughton | 67%
|
| Otto Kringelein | Lionel Barrymore | 67%
|
| Grandpa Martin Vanderhof | Lionel Barrymore | 67%
|
| Émile Zola | Paul Muni | 65%
|
| Baron Felix von Geigern | John Barrymore | 64%
|
| Anna Held | Luise Rainer | 64%
|
| Flaemmchen | Joan Crawford | 61%
|
| Tony Kirby | James Stewart | 54%
|
| Cadet White | Gary Cooper | 50%
|
| Florenz Ziegfeld, Jr. | William Powell | 49%
|
| Alice Sycamore | Jean Arthur | 45%
|
| Billie Burke | Myrna Loy | 43%
|
| Sabra Cravat | Irene Dunne | 41%
|
| Mary Preston | Clara Bow | 40%
|
| General Director Preysing | Wallace Beery | 39%
|
| Harriet "Hank" Mahoney | Bessie Love | 37%
|
| Byam | Franchot Tone | 35%
|
| Jack Powell | Charles "Buddy" Rogers | 34%
|
| Paul Baeumer | Lew Ayres | 33%
|
| Yancey Cravat | Richard Dix | 32%
|
| Jane Marryot | Diana Wynyard | 31%
|
| Captain Alfred Dreyfus | Joseph Schildkraut | 29%
|
| Fannie Brice | Fannie Brice | 27%
|
| David Armstrong | Richard Arlen | 23%
|
| Alexander Andrews | Walter Connolly | 21%
|
| Dixie Lee | Estelle Taylor | 19%
|
| Anthony P. Kirby | Edward Arnold | 18%
|
| Billings | Frank Morgan | 18%
|
| Lucie Dreyfus | Gale Sondergaard | 18%
|
| Potap Kolenkhov | Mischa Auer | 18%
|
| Maitre Labori | Donald Crisp | 17%
|
| Queenie Mahoney | Anita Page | 16%
|
| Robert Marryot | Clive Brook | 16%
|
| Alexandrine Zola | Gloria Holden | 16%
|
| Stanislaus Katczinsky | Louis Wolheim | 16%
|
| Felice Venable | Nance O'Neil | 16%
|
| Oscar Shapeley | Roscoe Karns | 16%
|
| Eddie Kearns | Charles King | 15%
|
| Ellison | Eddie Quillan | 15%
|
| Ellen Bridges | Una O'Connor | 15%
|
| "King" Westley | Jameson Thomas | 14%
|
| Himmelstoss | John Wray | 14%
|
| Alfred Bridges | Herbert Mundin | 13%
|
| Smith | Herbert Mundin | 13%
|
| Franz Kemmerich | Ben Alexander | 12%
|
| Sylvia Lewis | Jobyna Ralston | 12%
|
| Prof. Kantorek | Arnold Lucy | 11%
|
| Cook | Beryl Mercer | 11%
|
| Uncle Jed | Jed Prouty | 10%
|
| The Kid | William Collier, Jr. | 9%
|
| Jock | Kenneth Thomson | 7%
|
| 1927/28, 1st Academy Awards: Wings | x | 0%
|
| 1928/29, 2nd Academy Awards: The Broadway Melody | x | 0%
|
| 1929/30, 3rd Academy Awards: All Quiet on the Western Front | x | 0%
|
| 1930/31, 4th Academy Awards: Cimarron | x | 0%
|
| 1931/32, 5th Academy Awards: Grand Hotel | x | 0%
|
| 1932/33, 6th Academy Awards: Cavalcade | x | 0%
|
| 1934, 7th Academy Awards: It Happened One Night | x | 0%
|
| 1935, 8th Academy Awards: Mutiny on the Bounty | x | 0%
|
| 1936, 9th Academy Awards: The Great Ziegfeld | x | 0%
|
| 1937, 10th Academy Awards: The Life of Emile Zola | x | 0%
|
| 1938, 11th Academy Awards: You Can't Take It With You | x | 0%
|
| 1939, 12th Academy Awards: Gone with the Wind | x | 0%
|