| Role | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Rick Blaine | Humphrey Bogart | 97%
|
| Ilsa Lund | Ingrid Bergman | 93%
|
| Maxim de Winter | Laurence Olivier | 92%
|
| Hamlet | Laurence Olivier | 92%
|
| Fr. Chuck O'Malley | Bing Crosby | 73%
|
| Kay Miniver | Greer Garson | 72%
|
| The new Mrs. De Winter | Joan Fontaine | 71%
|
| Don Birnam | Ray Milland | 70%
|
| Willie Stark | Broderick Crawford | 64%
|
| Sgt. 1st Class Al Stephenson | Fredric March | 62%
|
| Philip Schuyler Green | Gregory Peck | 61%
|
| Capt. Louis Renault | Claude Rains | 57%
|
| Fr. Fitzgibbon | Barry Fitzgerald | 55%
|
| Carol Beldon | Teresa Wright | 46%
|
| Peggy Stephenson | Teresa Wright | 46%
|
| Milly Stephenson | Myrna Loy | 45%
|
| Mr . Gruffydd | Walter Pidgeon | 45%
|
| Clem Miniver | Walter Pidgeon | 45%
|
| Angharad Morgan | Maureen O'Hara | 44%
|
| Sadie Burke | Mercedes McCambridge | 42%
|
| Anne Dettrey | Celeste Holm | 40%
|
| Petty Officer 2nd Class Homer Parrish | Harold Russell | 40%
|
| Victor Laszlo | Paul Henreid | 40%
|
| Mrs. Danvers | Judith Anderson | 39%
|
| Helen St. James | Jane Wyman | 38%
|
| Gwilym Morgan | Donald Crisp | 35%
|
| Kathy Lacey | Dorothy McGuire | 33%
|
| Capt. Fred Derry | Dana Andrews | 32%
|
| Jack Favell | George Sanders | 30%
|
| Dave Goldman | John Garfield | 23%
|
| Philip's Mother | Anne Revere | 22%
|
| Jack Burden | John Ireland | 20%
|
| Maj. Heinrich Strasser | Conrad Veidt | 18%
|
| Mrs. Beth Morgan | Sara Allgood | 17%
|
| Lady Beldon | Dame May Whitty | 14%
|
| Huw Morgan | Roddy McDowall | 14%
|
| Tom Stark | John Derek | 13%
|
| Anne Stanton | Joanne Dru | 11%
|
| Frank Crawley | Reginald Denny | 10%
|
| Claudius | Basil Sydney | 8%
|
| Gertrude | Eileen Herlie | 8%
|
| Polonius | Felix Aylmer | 8%
|
| Fr. Timothy O'Dowd | Frank McHugh | 8%
|
| Ted Haines, Sr. | Gene Lockhart | 8%
|
| Ted Haines, Jr. | James Brown | 8%
|
| Nat | Howard Da Silva | 7%
|
| Horatio | Norman Wooland | 7%
|
| Foley | Reginald Owen | 7%
|
| Gloria | Doris Dowling | 6%
|
| Wick Birnam | Phillip Terry | 6%
|
| 1940, 13th Academy Awards: Rebecca | x | 2%
|
| 1941, 14th Academy Awards: How Green Was My Valley | x | 2%
|
| 1942, 15th Academy Awards: Mrs. Miniver | x | 2%
|
| 1943, 16th Academy Awards: Casablanca | x | 2%
|
| 1944, 17th Academy Awards: Going My Way | x | 2%
|
| 1945, 28th Academy Awards: The Lost Weekend | x | 2%
|
| 1946, 19th Academy Awards: The Best Years of Our Lives | x | 2%
|
| 1947, 20th Academy Awards: Gentleman’s Agreement | x | 2%
|
| 1948, 21st Academy Awards: Hamlet | x | 2%
|
| 1949, 22nd Academy Awards: All the King's Men | x | 2%
|