| Role | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Brad Braden | Charlton Heston | 91%
|
| Judah Ben-Hur | Charlton Heston | 91%
|
| Terry Malloy | Marlon Brando | 91%
|
| Lt.-Col. Nicholson | Alec Guinness | 79%
|
| 1st Sgt. Milton Warden | Burt Lancaster | 75%
|
| Pvt. Angelo Maggio | Frank Sinatra | 75%
|
| Jerry Mulligan | Gene Kelly | 74%
|
| Marty | Ernest Borgnine | 73%
|
| Margo Channing | Bette Davis | 67%
|
| Karen Holmes | Deborah Kerr | 66%
|
| Phileas Fogg | David Niven | 63%
|
| Cmdr. Shears | William Holden | 60%
|
| Lorene | Donna Reed | 53%
|
| Lise Bouvier | Leslie Caron | 53%
|
| Gigi | Leslie Caron | 53%
|
| Edie Doyle | Eva Marie Saint | 51%
|
| Pvt. Robert E. Lee Prewitt | Montgomery Clift | 51%
|
| Eve Harrington | Anne Baxter | 50%
|
| Buttons the Clown | James Stewart | 49%
|
| Father Barry | Karl Malden | 49%
|
| Addison DeWitt | George Sanders | 42%
|
| Honoré Lachaille | Maurice Chevalier | 42%
|
| Princess Aouda | Shirley MacLaine | 35%
|
| Karen Richards | Celeste Holm | 34%
|
| Charley "The Gent" Malloy | Rod Steiger | 34%
|
| Sheik Ilderim | Hugh Griffith | 33%
|
| Michael "Johnny Friendly" Skelly | Lee J. Cobb | 33%
|
| Gaston Lachaille | Louis Jourdan | 30%
|
| Maj. Warden | Jack Hawkins | 26%
|
| Quintus Arrius | Jack Hawkins | 26%
|
| Messala | Stephen Boyd | 26%
|
| Passepartout | Cantinflas | 25%
|
| Holly | Betty Hutton | 24%
|
| Col. Saito | Sessue Hayakawa | 24%
|
| Clara | Betsy Blair | 20%
|
| Madame Alvarez | Hermione Gingold | 19%
|
| The Great Sebastian | Cornel Wilde | 17%
|
| Bill Sampson | Gary Merrill | 16%
|
| Maj. Clipton | James Donald | 14%
|
| Phyllis | Dorothy Lamour | 13%
|
| Esther | Haya Harareet | 12%
|
| Angie | Joe Mantell | 12%
|
| Milo Roberts | Nina Foch | 12%
|
| Inspector Fix | Robert Newton | 12%
|
| Adam Cook | Oscar Levant | 11%
|
| Marty's mother | Esther Minciotti | 10%
|
| Aunt Alicia | Isabel Jeans | 10%
|
| Aunt Catherine | Augusta Ciolli | 9%
|
| Henri Baurel | Georges Guétary | 9%
|
| Gauthier Ralph | Robert Morley | 9%
|
| 1950, 23rd Academy Awards: All About Eve | x | 2%
|
| 1951, 24th Academy Awards: An American in Paris | x | 2%
|
| 1952, 25th Academy Awards: The Greatest Show on Earth | x | 2%
|
| 1953, 26th Academy Awards: From Here to Eternity | x | 2%
|
| 1954, 27th Academy Awards: On the Waterfront | x | 2%
|
| 1955, 28th Academy Awards: Marty | x | 2%
|
| 1956, 29th Academy Awards: Around the World in 80 Days | x | 2%
|
| 1957, 30th Academy Awards: The Bridge on the River Kwai | x | 2%
|
| 1958, 31st Academy Awards: Gigi | x | 2%
|
| 1959, 32nd Academy Awards: Ben-Hur | x | 2%
|