| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Owner of the Freak Show | Elsa Mars | 90%
|
| Spoiled Rich Kid, Turned Killer | Dandy Mott | 88%
|
| Lobster Man | Jimmy Darling | 87%
|
| Killer Clown | Twisty | 81%
|
| Two Headed Simease Twins | Bette and Dot | 78%
|
| Only Character Ever to Appear in Two Seasons | Pepper | 71%
|
| Is Portrayed by the World's Shortest Woman, Is a Member of the Freak Show | Ma Petite | 64%
|
| Came to the Freak Show on Halloween Night, Has a Second Face on the Back of His Head | Edward Mordrake | 60%
|
| Bearded Lady | Ethel Darling | 57%
|
| Con-Woman Who Works with the Above | Maggie Esmerelda | 54%
|
| Married to the Above, Known as the "Strong Man" | Dell Toledo | 48%
|
| Three-Breasted Woman | Desiree Dupree | 45%
|
| Mother of The Spoiled Kid | Gloria Mott | 42%
|
| Con-Man Looking to Kill the Simease Twins | Stanley | 38%
|
| Maid of The Above | Dora | 35%
|