| Description | Location | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Humanoid beast of the Pacific Northwest | Northwestern US | Bigfoot | 95%
|
| Said to live in Scotland's most famous lake | Scotland | Loch Ness Monster | 85%
|
| Hairy, mountain-dwelling giant ape | Himalayas | Yeti | 77%
|
| Reptile-like beast that preys on goats | Central/South America | Chupacabra | 76%
|
| Human-sized winged creature rumored to be connected to a deadly bridge collapse | West Virginia | Mothman | 69%
|
| Winged creature with a long neck and horse-like head | New Jersey | Jersey Devil | 60%
|
| Gigantic prehistoric shark rumored to still exist in some areas | Worldwide | Megalodon | 59%
|
| Magnificent giant bird linked to Native American legend | Southwestern US | Thunderbird | 49%
|
| Swamp-dwelling primate with a foul odor | Florida | Skunk Ape | 40%
|
| Giant, acid-spitting red desert worm | Mongolia | Mongolian Death Worm | 39%
|
| Devil-like being who leapt among rooftops | England | Spring Heeled Jack | 30%
|
| Elephant- or dinosaur-like river monster | Congo | Mokele Mbembe | 27%
|
| Monster that dwells in Australian swamps and billabongs | Australia | Bunyip | 25%
|
| Ten foot tall green monster with a red spade-shaped head | West Virginia | Flatwoods Monster | 20%
|
| Pudgy snake with the ability to jump and a taste for alcohol | Japan | Tsuchinoko | 12%
|
| Odd sea monster resembling a hairy aquatic elephant | South Africa | Trunko | 10%
|