| Clue | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The new girl | Jess | 100%
|
| Author of The Pepperwood Chronicles | Nick | 99%
|
| Opens their own modelling agency | Cece | 98%
|
| Has their own douchebag jar | Schmidt | 97%
|
| Their pranks are always either too big or too small | Winston | 95%
|
| Works as a personal trainer | Coach | 93%
|
| Nick's crazy ex-girlfriend | Caroline | 82%
|
| Daughter of previous two characters | Ruth | 69%
|
| Pediatrician who dates Jess twice | Sam | 68%
|
| Winston's police partner and later wife | Aly | 67%
|
| Winston's cat | Furguson | 63%
|
| Beer delivery guy who writes a musical about woodland creatures with Jess | Bearclaw | 61%
|
| Nick's silent mentor who he met on a park bench | Tran | 59%
|
| Jess's cousin who has dated both her and Cece | Robby | 56%
|
| Crazy Russian model | Nadia | 54%
|
| Jess's former fancyman who she later works for | Russel | 54%
|
| Homeless man who lives outside the apartment building | Outside Dave | 53%
|
| Schmidt's college girlfriend whom he later dates at the same time as Cece | Elizabeth | 52%
|
| Music teacher and Jess's ex-boyfriend | Paul | 52%
|
| City councilwoman who Schmidt dates | Fawn | 49%
|
| Pharmaceutical sales rep who Nick dates | Reagan | 49%
|
| English science teacher who Jess dates | Ryan | 45%
|
| Lesbian gynecologist | Sadie | 42%
|
| Cellist with whom Coach moves to New York | May | 38%
|
| Cece's fiance for her arranged marriage | Shivrang | 36%
|
| Jess's wild sister | Abby | 33%
|
| Jess's father | Bob | 29%
|
| Creepy landlord | Remi | 28%
|
| Son of Winston and Aly | Dan Bill | 24%
|
| Schmidt's second boss at Associated Strategies | Kim | 23%
|
| Schmidt's father who also kisses Jess | Gavin | 21%
|
| Eccentric headteacher at Coolidge Middle School where Jess works | Principal Foster | 18%
|
| Jess's mother | Joan | 13%
|
| Schmidt's mother | Louise | 8%
|