| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Nick's crazy ex-girlfriend who he nearly moved in with at the end of Series 1 | Caroline | 94%
|
| Jess and Cece's ex who is also related to Jess | Robby | 94%
|
| Jess's doctor ex who she dates twice over the series | Sam | 93%
|
| Schmidt's council woman ex | Fawn | 87%
|
| Jess's musical ex who she dates in Series 1 | Paul | 86%
|
| Nick's ex who sublets Jess's room while she is on jury duty | Reagan | 85%
|
| Schmidt's long term ex from college | Elizabeth | 84%
|
| Jess's British ex | Ryan | 84%
|
| Jess's ex who she lived with before moving to The Loft | Spencer | 81%
|
| Jess's fancy-man ex | Russel | 79%
|
| Cece's arranged marriage ex-fiancee | Shivrang | 75%
|
| Winston's prankster ex-wife | Rhonda | 73%
|
| Schmidt's ex who was also Jess's sister | Abby | 71%
|
| Winston's ex who dresses up as 'reigning cats and dogs' for Halloween | Shelby | 69%
|
| Winston's ex who he steals his cat Ferguson from | Daisy | 53%
|
| Nick's lawyer ex from Series 1 | Julia | 42%
|
| Nick's ex-girlfriend who was also Tran's granddaughter | Kai | 41%
|
| Nick's stripper ex | Angie | 26%
|
| Winston's ex who he meets by Nick letting Ferguson escape | Bertie | 19%
|
| Cece's ex who she casually dated in Series 1 | Kyle | 19%
|
| Winston's ex who he initially hid his profession as a police officer from | KC | 18%
|