| Departing Artist | Musical Act | Commercial Breakthrough | Replaced By | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pete Best | The Beatles | 1963 | Ringo Starr | 98%
|
| Tracii Guns | Guns N' Roses | 1987 | Slash | 88%
|
| Kim Hill | Black Eyed Peas | 2000 | Fergie | 85%
|
| Chad Channing | Nirvana | 1991 | Dave Grohl | 85%
|
| Doug Sandom | The Who | 1965 | Keith Moon | 85%
|
| Tony Chapman | The Rolling Stones | 1963 | Charlie Watts | 83%
|
| Niall Quinn | The Cranberries | 1993 | Dolores O'Riordan | 79%
|
| Michelle Stephenson | Spice Girls | 1996 | Emma Bunton | 77%
|
| Jeff Thomas | Duran Duran | 1981 | Simon Le Bon | 75%
|
| Scott Raynor | Blink-182 | 1999 | Travis Barker | 73%
|
| Mark Wahlberg | New Kids on the Block | 1988 | Joey McIntyre | 69%
|
| Jason Galasso | NSYNC | 1997 | Lance Bass | 69%
|
| Jeff Jones | Rush | 1974 | Geddy Lee | 60%
|
| Crystal Jones | TLC | 1992 | Rozonda "Chilli" Thomas | 54%
|
| Támar Davis;Nikki and Nina Taylor | Destiny's Child | 1997 | LeToya Luckett | 29%
|
| Chris Salih | Twenty One Pilots | 2015 | Josh Dun | 23%
|
| Scott Sundquist | Soundgarden | 1990 | Matt Cameron | 21%
|
| Elbridge Bryant | The Temptations | 1964 | David Ruffin | 19%
|
| Josh Brainard | Slipknot | 1999 | Jim Root | 13%
|
| Matt Pelissier | My Chemical Romance | 2004 | Bob Bryar | 8%
|