| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Falls in love with a stable worker | Regina | 98%
|
| Half-sister to #1 | Zelena | 84%
|
| Switches bodies with Henry | Peter Pan | 83%
|
| Hired #2 to get Princess Aurora's heart in the Enchanted Forest | Cora | 65%
|
| Is briefly engaged to Neal Cassidy | Tamara | 60%
|
| Causes someone to lose their memory by shooting a gun | Captain Hook | 58%
|
| Runs the ice cream shop | Ingrid | 57%
|
| Kept the first curse in the orb above their staff | Maleficent | 55%
|
| Advises #1 from behind glass | Sidney | 53%
|
| Dates Emma in New York | Walsh | 47%
|
| Hits Hook with a car | Greg | 42%
|
| This person gets what they want only by saying "please" | Rumpelstiltskin | 21%
|