| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| (male) the killer | Jeff | 96%
|
| Drowned | Ben | 93%
|
| (female) the killer | jane | 93%
|
| Always watches, no eyes | Slenderman | 89%
|
| Kidney eater | Eyeless jack | 86%
|
| "Pop goes the Weasel" | Laughing Jack | 79%
|
| "Will you play with me?" | Sally | 76%
|
| Minecraft | Herobrine | 75%
|
| Loves cheesecake | Masky | 69%
|
| "Spread the word" | Smile dog | 66%
|
| Crouching Humainoid | Rake | 62%
|
| Kills with pills | Hoodie | 54%
|
| Mickey Mouse | Suicidemouse.ovi | 49%
|
| Cartoon Character | Squidward | 40%
|
| "He Comes" | Zalgo | 39%
|
| "He died" | Lost Silver | 35%
|
| "Can you feel the sunshine" | Tails doll | 31%
|
| Skeleton marionette, | The Skin Taker | 28%
|
| "A Princess? Or a Psychopath?" | Angelica | 7%
|