| City | League | Athlete | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York | MLB | Babe Ruth | 91%
|
| Boston | NBA | Bill Russell | 82%
|
| Boston | NFL | Tom Brady | 82%
|
| Philadelphia | NBA | Allen Iverson | 73%
|
| Atlanta | NBA | Dominique Wilkins | 73%
|
| Miami | NBA | Dwyane Wade | 73%
|
| Philadelphia | NBA | Julius Erving | 73%
|
| Miami | NFL | Dan Marino | 64%
|
| Washington | NBA | Wes Unseld | 64%
|
| New York | NFL | Lawrence Taylor | 55%
|
| Boston | MLB | Ted Williams | 55%
|
| New York | NBA | Walt Frazier | 55%
|
| Washington | NHL | Alex Ovechkin | 45%
|
| Boston | NHL | Bobby Orr | 45%
|
| Atlanta | MLB | Chipper Jones | 45%
|
| Atlanta | MLB | Hank Aaron | 45%
|
| Miami | NBA | Alonzo Mourning | 36%
|
| Philadelphia | NHL | Bobby Clarke | 36%
|
| New York | MLB | Lou Gehrig | 36%
|
| Philadelphia | MLB | Mike Schmidt | 36%
|
| Washington | NFL | Darrell Green | 18%
|
| Atlanta | MLB | Tom Glavine | 18%
|
| Miami | NFL | Bob Griese | 9%
|
| Washington | MLB | Walter Johnson | 0%
|