| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| German church reformer/Civil rights activist | Martin Luther/Martin Luther King, Jr. | 92%
|
| Lead singer of The Monkees/Tentacle-bearded pirate in "Pirates of the Caribbean" | Davy Jones/Davy Jones | 65%
|
| President of the United States/Revolutionary peanut farmer | George Washington/George Washington Carver | 51%
|
| Drummer for Queen/Drummer for Duran Duran | Roger Taylor/Roger Taylor | 51%
|
| Singer of The Beach Boys/Bearded MLB pitcher | Brian Wilson/Brian Wilson | 49%
|
| Former American Idol judge/Former member of his family band | Randy Jackson/Randy Jackson | 49%
|
| Offensive radio host/Attorney and former domestic partner of Anna Nicole Smith | Howard Stern/Howard Stern | 46%
|
| Actor and producer, seen in "Wall Street"/Actor and producer, seen in "Batman" | Michael Douglas/Michael Douglas (Keaton) | 41%
|
| Former SNL actor/Famous movie murderer | Mike Myers/Michael Myers | 30%
|
| Famous scientist/Actor in "Broadcast News", "Finding Nemo" | Albert Einstein/Albert Einstein (Brooks) | 27%
|
| Creator of "The X-Files"/Former wide receiver for the Minnesota Vikings | Chris Carter/Cris Carter | 24%
|
| Lead Guitarist for The Clash/Lead Guitarist for Foreigner | Mick Jones/Mick Jones | 24%
|
| Basketball legend of the Los Angeles Lakers/Former running back of the Miami Dolphins | Kareem Abdul-Jabbar/Karim Abdul-Jabbar | 16%
|
| President of the United States/MLB Hall of Fame pitcher from 1911-1930 | Grover Cleveland/Grover Cleveland Alexander | 14%
|
| American film star of the 1950s/American porn actor | James Dean/James Deen | 14%
|