| Years | Players | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 1920's | Babe Ruth | 95%
|
| Tommy Bond | 93%
| |
| Alex Rodriguez | 91%
| |
| 1930's | Lou Gehrig | 88%
|
| 1950's | Mickey Mantle | 88%
|
| Randy Johnson | 86%
| |
| Walter Johnson | 86%
| |
| 1990's | Barry Bonds | 84%
|
| Ted Williams | 81%
| |
| 1940's | Joe DiMaggio | 79%
|
| Willie Mays | 79%
| |
| 2010's | Mike Trout | 74%
|
| 1910's | Ty Cobb | 74%
|
| Hank Aaron | 70%
| |
| 2000's | Albert Pujols | 67%
|
| 1900's | Cy Young | 67%
|
| Honus Wagner | 67%
| |
| 1980's | Mike Schmidt | 65%
|
| Clayton Kershaw | 63%
| |
| Jimmie Foxx | 63%
| |
| Miguel Cabrera | 63%
| |
| Rickey Henderson | 60%
| |
| 1960's | Sandy Koufax | 60%
|
| Bob Gibson | 58%
| |
| Rogers Hornsby | 56%
| |
| Cal Ripken Jr. | 53%
| |
| 1880's | Cap Anson | 51%
|
| Stan Musial | 51%
| |
| Tom Seaver | 51%
| |
| Christy Mathewson | 47%
| |
| 1970's | Joe Morgan | 47%
|
| Warren Spahn | 47%
| |
| Frank Thomas | 44%
| |
| Greg Maddux | 44%
| |
| Rod Carew | 44%
| |
| Lefty Grove | 37%
| |
| Grover Cleveland Alexander | 23%
| |
| Kid Nichols | 21%
| |
| Billy Hamilton | 14%
| |
| Dazzy Vance | 12%
| |
| Tim Keefe | 12%
| |
| Charley Radbourn | 7%
| |
| 1890's | Dan Brouthers | 7%
|
| 1870's | George Wright | 2%
|
| Al Spalding | 0%
| |
| 1860's | Jim Creighton | 0%
|