| Team | Pos | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona Diamondbacks | P | Randy Johnson | 100%
|
| Minnesota Twins | P | Walter Johnson | 96%
|
| Baltimore Orioles | SS | Cal Ripken Jr. | 94%
|
| Atlanta Braves | OF | Hank Aaron | 94%
|
| New York Yankees | OF | Babe Ruth | 91%
|
| Boston Red Sox | OF | Ted Williams | 91%
|
| Seattle Mariners | OF | Ken Griffey Jr. | 85%
|
| Chicago White Sox | 1B | Frank Thomas | 83%
|
| Los Angeles Angels | OF | Mike Trout | 83%
|
| Cincinnati Reds | C | Johnny Bench | 81%
|
| San Francisco Giants | OF | Willie Mays | 81%
|
| Philadelphia Phillies | 3B | Mike Schmidt | 79%
|
| Kansas City Royals | 3B | George Brett | 77%
|
| Miami Marlins | OF | Giancarlo Stanton | 77%
|
| San Diego Padres | OF | Tony Gwynn | 77%
|
| Houston Astros | P | Nolan Ryan | 74%
|
| New York Mets | P | Tom Seaver | 74%
|
| Texas Rangers | C | Ivan Rodriguez | 72%
|
| Oakland Athletics | OF | Rickey Henderson | 72%
|
| Los Angeles Dodgers | P | Sandy Koufax | 72%
|
| Milwaukee Brewers | SS/OF | Robin Yount | 70%
|
| Pittsburgh Pirates | SS | Honus Wagner | 66%
|
| St. Louis Cardinals | OF/1B | Stan Musial | 66%
|
| Colorado Rockies | 1B | Todd Helton | 66%
|
| Detroit Tigers | OF | Ty Cobb | 66%
|
| Toronto Blue Jays | P | Roy Halladay | 57%
|
| Washington Nationals | C | Gary Carter | 51%
|
| Cleveland Indians | 2B | Nap Lajoie | 34%
|
| Tampa Bay Rays | 1B | Fred McGriff | 23%
|
| Chicago Cubs | 1B | Cap Anson | 21%
|