| Teams | Order/Position | Players | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3. RF | Babe Ruth | 97%
| |
| 4. 1B | Lou Gehrig | 95%
| |
| 4. DH | David Ortiz | 80%
| |
| 4. LF | Jackie Robinson | 80%
| |
| 3. 1B | Albert Pujols | 72%
| |
| 5. C | Johnny Bench | 72%
| |
| 3. LF | Manny Ramirez | 72%
| |
| 7. RF | Manny Ramirez | 72%
| |
| 1976 Cincinnati Reds | 1. 3B | Pete Rose | 72%
|
| 2. C | Ivan Rodriguez | 69%
| |
| 2. RF | Larry Walker | 69%
| |
| 3. RF | Larry Walker | 69%
| |
| 2. SS | Pee Wee Reese | 69%
| |
| 3. CF | Duke Snider | 66%
| |
| 3. 2B | Joe Morgan | 66%
| |
| 6. 3B | Jim Thome | 64%
| |
| 2004 Boston Red Sox | 1. CF | Johnny Damon | 57%
|
| 1995 Cleveland Indians | 1. CF | Kenny Lofton | 57%
|
| 4. LF | Albert Belle | 54%
| |
| 4. RF | Juan Gonzalez | 54%
| |
| 6. C | Jason Varitek | 52%
| |
| 6. C | Roy Campanella | 52%
| |
| 4. 1B | Hank Greenberg | 51%
| |
| 2. SS | Omar Vizquel | 51%
| |
| 6. 1B | Tony Perez | 48%
| |
| 5. LF | Dante Bichette | 46%
| |
| 4. LF | George Foster | 46%
| |
| 5. 1B | Kevin Millar | 46%
| |
| 4. 1B | Andres Galarraga | 44%
| |
| 6. SS | Edgar Renteria | 43%
| |
| 5. CF | Jim Edmonds | 41%
| |
| 2. RF | Ken Griffey (Sr.) | 41%
| |
| 1997 Colorado Rockies | 1. 2B | Eric Young | 39%
|
| 5. DH | Rafael Palmeiro | 39%
| |
| 7. RF | Pete Fox | 38%
| |
| 8. SS | Dave Concepcion | 36%
| |
| 5. 1B | Gil Hodges | 36%
| |
| 2. CF | Ellis Burks | 34%
| |
| 6. 3B | Vinny Castilla | 34%
| |
| 3. 2B | Carlos Baerga | 33%
| |
| 4. 3B | Scott Rolen | 33%
| |
| 7. RF | Trot Nixon | 28%
| |
| 9. 3B | Bill Mueller | 26%
| |
| 3. 2B | Charlie Gehringer | 26%
| |
| 3. RF | Chuck Klein | 23%
| |
| 7. CF | Cesar Geronimo | 18%
| |
| 2. C | Mickey Cochrane | 18%
| |
| 8. SS | Orlando Cabrera | 18%
| |
| 8. C | Pat Collins | 18%
| |
| 6. 2B | Tony Lazzeri | 18%
| |
| 1927 New York Yankees | 1. CF | Earle Combs | 16%
|
| 5. DH | Eddie Murray | 16%
| |
| 7. SS | Walt Weiss | 15%
| |
| 5. LF | Bob Meusel | 13%
| |
| 1935 Detroit Tigers | 1. CF | Jo-Jo White | 13%
|
| 2. 2B | Mark Bellhorn | 13%
| |
| 8. C | Mike Matheny | 13%
| |
| 7. RF | Carl Furillo | 11%
| |
| 7. RF | Reggie Sanders | 11%
| |
| 1929 Philadelphia Phillies | 1. 2B | Fresco Thompson | 10%
|
| 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers | 1. 2B | Jim Gilliam | 10%
|
| 9. C | Tony Pena | 10%
| |
| 8. 1B | Paul Sorrento | 8%
| |
| 3. LF | Rusty Greer | 8%
| |
| 2004 St. Louis Cardinals | 1. 2B | Tony Womack | 8%
|
| 2. SS | Mark Koenig | 7%
| |
| 6. 3B | Todd Zeile | 7%
| |
| 8. 3B | Billy Cox | 5%
| |
| 5. LF | Goose Goslin | 5%
| |
| 7. 3B | Joe Dugan | 5%
| |
| 2. LF | Lefty O'Doul | 5%
| |
| 1999 Texas Rangers | 1. 2B | Mark McLemore | 5%
|
| 4. 1B | Don Hurst | 3%
| |
| 6. CF | Bernie Friberg | 2%
| |
| 6. SS | Billy Rogell | 2%
| |
| 8. C | Kirt Manwaring | 2%
| |
| 7. 1B | Lee Stevens | 2%
| |
| 8. 3B | Marv Owen | 2%
| |
| 5. 3B | Pinky Whitney | 2%
| |
| 8. SS | Royce Clayton | 2%
| |
| 9. CF | Tom Goodwin | 2%
| |
| 7. SS | Tommy Thevenow | 2%
| |
| 8. C | Walt Lerian | 2%
|