| Position | Age | Hometown | Profession | Status | Contestant | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2nd | 22 | Barrington, RI | College Student | Eliminated September 18 | Nick DiGiovanni | 100%
|
| 8th | 24 | Dallas, TX | Cocktail Server | Eliminated August 21 | Brielle “Bri” Baker | 92%
|
| 1st | 45 | Cartersville, GA | Creeler | Winner September 18 | Dorian Hunter | 92%
|
| 2nd | 31 | San Diego, CA | Former Army Interrogator | Runner-up September 18 | Sarah Faherty | 92%
|
| 4th | 32 | Epworth, GA | Septic Service Technician | Eliminated September 11 | Noah Sims | 88%
|
| 5th | 54 | West Nyack, NY | R&D Director | Eliminated September 4 | Subha Ramiah | 88%
|
| 11th | 30 | Bronx, NY | English Teacher | Eliminated August 1 | Wuta Onda | 88%
|
| 10th | 24 | Redondo Beach, CA | Revenue Analyst | Eliminated August 8 | Fred Chang | 85%
|
| 15th | 53 | Durand, MI | Events Consultant | Eliminated July 11 | Elizabeth “Liz” Linn | 81%
|
| 9th | 42 | Pawleys Island, SC | Fisherman | Eliminated August 15 | Jamie Hough | 81%
|
| 7th | 19 | Grand Rapids, MI | Kitchen Porter | Eliminated August 28 | Micah Yaroch | 81%
|
| 15th | 31 | Pittsburgh, PA | Real Estate Flipper | Eliminated July 11 | Michael Silverstein | 81%
|
| 13th | 35 | Philadelphia, PA | Attorney | Eliminated July 25 | Samuel “Sam” Haaz | 81%
|
| 5th | 34 | Rochester, MN | Stay-at-Home Mom | Eliminated September 4 | Shari Mukherjee | 81%
|
| 14th | 30 | London, England | Freelance Writer | Eliminated July 18 | Keturah King | 77%
|
| 12th | 33 | Ada, OK | Receptionist | Eliminated July 31 | Renee Rice | 73%
|
| 17th | 36 | Brooklyn, NY | Sales Coordinator | Eliminated June 27 | Evan Tesiny | 69%
|
| 19th | 46 | Boston, MA | Carpenter | Eliminated June 12 | Kenneth “Kenny” Palazzolo | 65%
|
| 18th | 31 | New York, NY | Shoe Designer | Eliminated June 20 | Kimberly White | 54%
|
| 19th | 45 | Simi Valley, CA | Vocal Coach | Eliminated June 12 | Deanna Colon | 46%
|