| Position: | Years Active: | Player: | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forward | 2005-2015 | Lionel Messi | 98%
|
| Midfielder | 1977-1994 | Diego Maradona | 94%
|
| Forward | 1991-2002 | Gabriel Batistuta | 74%
|
| Defender | 1994-2011 | Javier Zanetti | 64%
|
| Midfielder | 2003-2015 | Javier Mascherano | 62%
|
| Midfielder | 1947* | Alfredo Di Stéfano | 54%
|
| Defender | 1974-1986 | Daniel Passarella | 41%
|
| Goalkeeper | 1974-1985 | Ubaldo Fillol | 31%
|
| Defender | 1983-1994 | Oscar Ruggeri | 27%
|
| Forward | 1936–1950 | José Manuel Moreno | 12%
|
| Defender | 1960-1969 | Silvio Marzolini | 10%
|