| Month Won | Club | Nationality | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 2015 | Manchester United | Anthony Martial | 100%
| |
| December 2011 | Newcastle United | Demba Ba | 100%
| |
| January 2024 | Liverpool | Diogo Jota | 100%
| |
| August 2011 | Manchester City | Edin Dzeko | 100%
| |
| March 2012 | Swansea City | Gylfi Sigurdsson | 100%
| |
| November/December 2022 | Arsenal | Martin Odegaard | 100%
| |
| March 2017 | Everton | Romelu Lukaku | 100%
| |
| August 2019 | Norwich City | Teemu Pukki | 100%
| |
| April 2018 | Crystal Palace | Wilfried Zaha | 100%
| |
| September 2013 | Arsenal | Aaron Ramsey | 80%
| |
| August 2015 | Swansea City | Andre Ayew | 80%
| |
| September 2011 | Manchester City | David Silva | 80%
| |
| January 2017 | Tottenham Hotspur | Dele Alli | 80%
| |
| December 2023 | Bournemouth | Dominic Solanke | 80%
| |
| April 2002 | Arsenal | Frederik Ljungberg | 80%
| |
| November 2023 | Manchester United | Harry Maguire | 80%
| |
| August 2023 | Tottenham Hotspur | James Maddison | 80%
| |
| March 2013 | Tottenham Hotspur | Jan Vertonghen | 80%
| |
| August 2009 | Tottenham Hotspur | Jermain Defoe | 80%
| |
| February 2022 | Liverpool | Joel Matip | 80%
| |
| March 2021 | Leicester City | Kelechi Iheanacho | 80%
| |
| October 2017 | Manchester City | Leroy Sane | 80%
| |
| August 2018 | Tottenham Hotspur | Lucas Moura | 80%
| |
| October 2022 | Newcastle United | Miguel Almiron | 80%
| |
| December 2015 | Watford | Odion Ighalo | 80%
| |
| March 2015 | Arsenal | Olivier Giroud | 80%
| |
| February 2024 | Manchester United | Rasmus Hojlund | 80%
| |
| February 2003 | Arsenal | Robert Pires | 80%
| |
| December 2016 | Manchester United | Zlatan Ibrahimovic | 80%
| |
| November 1997 | Manchester United | Andrew Cole | 60%
| |
| April 2009 | Arsenal | Andrey Arshavin | 60%
| |
| January 2006 | West Ham United | Anton Ferdinand | 60%
| |
| March 2023 | Arsenal | Bukayo Saka | 60%
| |
| December 2009 | Manchester City | Carlos Tevez | 60%
| |
| December 2014 | Queens Park Rangers | Charlie Austin | 60%
| |
| April 2015 | Aston Villa | Christian Benteke | 60%
| |
| August 2005 | Charlton Athletic | Darren Bent | 60%
| |
| January 2022 | Manchester United | David de Gea | 60%
| |
| March 2010 | Chelsea | Florent Malouda | 60%
| |
| April 2001 | Liverpool | Gary McAllister | 60%
| |
| September 2014 | Southampton | Graziano Pelle | 60%
| |
| November 2003 | Bolton Wanderers | Jay-Jay Okocha | 60%
| |
| March 2005 | Chelsea | Joe Cole | 60%
| |
| January 2005 | Chelsea | John Terry | 60%
| |
| August 2004 | Arsenal | Jose Antonio Reyes | 60%
| |
| October 2012 | Chelsea | Juan Mata | 60%
| |
| January 2002 | Ipswich Town | Marcus Bent | 60%
| |
| November 2012 | Everton | Maroune Fellaini | 60%
| |
| August 1998 | Liverpool | Michael Owen | 60%
| |
| January 2009 | Manchester United | Nemanja Vidic | 60%
| |
| April 2012 | Everton | Nikica Jelavic | 60%
| |
| March 2007 | Chelsea | Petr Cech | 60%
| |
| October 2010 | Tottenham Hotspur | Rafael van der Vaart | 60%
| |
| March 1999 | Arsenal | Ray Parlour | 60%
| |
| March 2024 | Fulham | Rodrigo Muniz | 60%
| |
| January 2014 | Sunderland | Adam Johnson | 40%
| |
| April 1996 | Everton | Andrei Kanchelskis | 40%
| |
| November 2004 | Chelsea | Arjen Robben | 40%
| |
| March 2011 | Chelsea | David Luiz | 40%
| |
| April 1995 | Arsenal | David Seaman | 40%
| |
| October 2014 | West Ham United | Diafra Sakho | 40%
| |
| September 2020 | Everton | Dominic Calvert-Lewin | 40%
| |
| February 2004 | Arsenal | Edu Gaspar | 40%
| |
| April 1998 | Arsenal | Emmanuel Petit | 40%
| |
| March 1996 | Manchester United | Eric Cantona | 40%
| |
| February 2016 | Southampton | Fraser Forster | 40%
| |
| November 2007 | Aston Villa | Gabriel Agbonlahor | 40%
| |
| November 1996 | Arsenal | Ian Wright | 40%
| |
| May 2021 | Newcastle United | Joe Willock | 40%
| |
| November 2010 | Bolton Wanderers | Johan Elmander | 40%
| |
| September 2001 | Manchester United | Juan Sebastian Veron | 40%
| |
| March 1997 | Middlesbrough | Juninho | 40%
| |
| August 1994 | Tottenham Hotspur | Jurgen Klinsmann | 40%
| |
| April 1999 | Everton | Kevin Campbell | 40%
| |
| February 2006 | Bolton Wanderers | Kevin Nolan | 40%
| |
| October 1999 | Sunderland | Kevin Phillips | 40%
| |
| September 2004 | Tottenham Hotspur | Ledley King | 40%
| |
| August 2001 | Fulham | Louis Saha | 40%
| |
| February 2010 | Fulham | Mark Schwarzer | 40%
| |
| August 2007 | Manchester City | Micah Richards | 40%
| |
| September 1996 | Liverpool | Patrik Berger | 40%
| |
| October 1994 | Manchester United | Paul Ince | 40%
| |
| November 1999 | Liverpool | Sami Hyypia | 40%
| |
| December 2010 | Arsenal | Samir Nasri | 40%
| |
| September 2012 | Sunderland | Steven Fletcher | 40%
| |
| August 2002 | Arsenal | Sylvain Wiltord | 40%
| |
| November 2013 | Newcastle United | Tim Krul | 40%
| |
| January 2013 | Reading | Adam Le Fondre | 20%
| |
| August 2000 | Leeds United | Alan Smith | 20%
| |
| August 2008 | Chelsea | Deco | 20%
| |
| February 1995 | Everton | Duncan Ferguson | 20%
| |
| April 2021 | West Ham United | Jesse Lingard | 20%
| |
| November 1997 | Southampton | Kevin Davies | 20%
| |
| September 1999 | Leicester City | Muzzy Izzet | 20%
| |
| October 1997 | Derby County | Paulo Wanchope | 20%
| |
| November 2000 | Leeds United | Paul Robinson | 20%
| |
| February 2009 | Everton | Phil Jagielka | 20%
| |
| February 1997 | Wimbledon | Robbie Earle | 20%
| |
| December 2007 | Blackburn Rovers | Roque Santa Cruz | 20%
| |
| December 1997 | Liverpool | Steve McManaman | 20%
| |
| October 1995 | Queens Park Rangers | Trevor Sinclair | 20%
| |
| March 1998 | Arsenal | Alex Manninger | 0%
| |
| January 1995 | Sheffield Wednesday | Chris Waddle | 0%
| |
| April 2014 | Sunderland | Connor Wickham | 0%
| |
| January 2000 | Aston Villa | Gareth Southgate | 0%
| |
| November 2009 | Hull City | Jimmy Bullard | 0%
| |
| April 1997 | Southampton | Mickey Evans | 0%
| |
| March 2004 | Birmingham City | Mikael Forssell | 0%
| |
| February 2000 | Aston Villa | Paul Merson | 0%
| |
| January 1996 | Liverpool | Stan Collymore | 0%
| |
| February 2001 | West Ham United | Stuart Pearce | 0%
|