| Position | Clubs | Years | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MID | Swansea, Spurs, Everton | 2011-21 | Gylfi Sigurdsson | 95%
|
| DEF | West Brom | 2002-03 | Larus Sigurdsson | 91%
|
| ATT | Chelsea, Spurs, Stoke, Fulham | 2000-06, 2009-11 | Eidur Gudjohnsen | 68%
|
| MID | Burnley | 2016-22, 2023-24 | Johann Berg Gudmundsson | 64%
|
| MID | Watford | 1999-2000 | Johann Birnir Gudmundsson | 64%
|
| GK | Arsenal | 2020-21 | Runar Alex Runarsson | 59%
|
| MID | Cardiff | 2013-14, 2018-19 | Aron Gunnarsson | 50%
|
| MID | Reading | 2006-08 | Brynjar Gunnarsson | 50%
|
| GK | Brentford | 2024-present | Hakon Valdimarsson | 41%
|
| DEF | Crystal Palace, Wimbledon, Ipswich, Charlton, Portsmouth | 1997-98, 1999-2002, 2003-10 | Hermann Hreidarsson | 41%
|
| MID | Aston Villa, Wolves, Burnley | 2002-04, 2009-10 | Joey Gudjonsson | 27%
|
| MID/ATT | Derby | 2000-01 | Thordur Gudjonsson | 27%
|
| MID | Wolves | 2011-12 | Eggert Jonsson | 23%
|
| DEF | Bolton | 2007-12 | Gretar Steinsson | 23%
|
| DEF | Spurs, Bolton | 1992-93, 1995-96, 1997-98, 2001-03 | Gudni Bergsson | 23%
|
| ATT | Watford, Fulham, Bolton, QPR | 1999-2000, 2005-09, 2011-12 | Heidar Helguson | 23%
|
| ATT | Bolton, Leicester | 1997-2002 | Arnar Gunnlaugsson | 18%
|
| DEF | Reading | 2006-08 | Ivar Ingimarsson | 18%
|
| MID | Forest | 1992-93 | Thorvaldur Orlygsson | 14%
|