| Hint | Character | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Protagonist | Arthur Morgan | 99%
|
| 3 | Van der Linde gang leader | Dutch van der Linde | 99%
|
| 2 | Secondary protagonist | John Marston | 98%
|
| 40 | Valentine Indian hunter | Jon | 95%
|
| 4 | Van der Linde gang co-founder | Hosea Matthews | 94%
|
| 5 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Bill Williamson | 92%
|
| 7 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Micah Bell | 91%
|
| 6 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Javier Escuella | 88%
|
| 8 | Van der Linde gang gunwoman | Sadie Adler | 88%
|
| 9 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Charles Smith | 86%
|
| 10 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Lenny Summers | 86%
|
| 23 | Van der Linde gang member | Jack Marston | 80%
|
| 82 | Love interest of #1 | Mary Linton | 78%
|
| 22 | Van der Linde gang cook | Simon Pearson | 78%
|
| 24 | Van der Linde gang member | Abigail Roberts | 77%
|
| 16 | Van der Linde gang member | Karen Jones | 77%
|
| 11 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Sean MacGuire | 77%
|
| 17 | Van der Linde gang member | Tilly Jackson | 75%
|
| 14 | Van der Linde gang member | Susan Grimshaw | 74%
|
| 27 | O'Driscoll Boys leader | Colm O'Driscoll | 72%
|
| 18 | Van der Linde gang bookkeeper | Leopold Strauss | 72%
|
| 13 | Van der Linde gang member | Uncle | 70%
|
| 12 | Van der Linde gang gunman | Kieran Duffy | 69%
|
| 30 | Pinkerton agent | Andrew Milton | 68%
|
| 15 | Van der Linde gang member | Molly O'Shea | 66%
|
| 19 | Van der Linde gang member | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 64%
|
| 21 | Van der Linde gang preacher | Orville Swanson | 64%
|
| 31 | Pinkerton agent | Edgar Ross | 62%
|
| 204 | Bounty target | Ellie Anne Swan | 58%
|
| 20 | Van der Linde gang member | Josiah Trelawny | 58%
|
| 63 | Relative of #62 | Beau Gray | 52%
|
| 28 | Industry tychoon | Leviticus Cornwall | 52%
|
| 66 | Rhodes sheriff (1899) | Leigh Gray | 50%
|
| 80 | Wapiti Indian | Eagle Flies | 48%
|
| 62 | Rival family patriarch | Tavish Gray | 48%
|
| 57 | Rhodes family matriarch | Catherine Braithwaite | 47%
|
| 64 | Relative of #62 | Iain Gray | 46%
|
| 79 | Wapiti Indian | Rains Fall | 46%
|
| 65 | Relative of #62 | Scott Gray | 46%
|
| 58 | Relative of #57 | Penelope Braithwaite | 45%
|
| 77 | Italian crime boss | Angelo Bronte | 41%
|
| 229 | Wife of #228 | Edith Downes | 39%
|
| 59 | Relative of #57 | Gareth Braithwaite | 39%
|
| 60 | Relative of #57 | Gerald Braithwaite | 39%
|
| 61 | Relative of #57 | Gertrude Braithwaite | 39%
|
| 228 | Debtor | Thomas Downes | 39%
|
| 25 | Van der Linde gang member | Cleet | 38%
|
| 98 | Saint Denis street urchin | Cleet | 38%
|
| 26 | Van der Linde gang member | Joe | 38%
|
| 230 | Son of #228 and #229 | Archie Downes | 37%
|
| 67 | Rhodes sheriff (1907) | Harmon Thomas | 32%
|
| 187 | Outlaw on the run | Sampson Black | 32%
|
| 113 | Lagras boatman | Thomas | 32%
|
| 116 | Guarma colonel | Alberto Fussar | 29%
|
| 49 | Emerald Ranch fence | Seamus | 28%
|
| 193 | Gunslinger | Black Belle | 27%
|
| 197 | Gunslinger | Jim "Boy" Calloway | 27%
|
| 194 | Gunslinger | Billy Midnight | 26%
|
| 83 | Brother of #82 | Jamie Gillis | 26%
|
| 37 | Valentine stable owner | Amos Levi | 25%
|
| 88 | Saint Denis inventor | Andrew Bell III | 25%
|
| 196 | Gunslinger | Flaco Hernandéz | 25%
|
| 174 | Veteran and outdoorsman | Hamish Sinclair | 25%
|
| 156 | Wildlife photographer | Albert Mason | 24%
|
| 195 | Gunslinger | Emmet Granger | 23%
|
| 177 | One-armed veteran | Mickey | 23%
|
| 118 | Guarma revolutionary | Hercule Fontaine | 21%
|
| 188 | Outlaw on the run | Wendell White | 21%
|
| 121 | Guarma interrogator | Angel | 20%
|
| 43 | Valentine brawler | Tommy | 20%
|
| 141 | Pronghorn Ranch farmhand | Abe | 19%
|
| 85 | Saint Denis monk | Brother Dorkins | 19%
|
| 136 | Pronghorn Ranch owner | David Geddes | 19%
|
| 139 | Son of #136 and #137 | Duncan Geddes | 19%
|
| 110 | Saint Denis mayor | Henri Lémieux | 19%
|
| 46 | Recognises #1 in Valentine | Jimmy Brooks | 19%
|
| 165 | Dwarf magician | Magnifico | 19%
|
| 115 | Croatian inventor | Marko Dragic | 19%
|
| 138 | Son of #136 and #137 | Angus Geddes | 18%
|
| 199 | Bounty target | Anthony Foreman | 18%
|
| 39 | Valentine doctor | Ben Calloway | 18%
|
| 169 | Roanoke Ridge widow | Charlotte Balfour | 18%
|
| 137 | Wife of #136 | Mrs. Geddes | 18%
|
| 81 | Wapiti Indian | Paytah | 18%
|
| 68 | Rhodes deputy | Archibald MacGregor | 17%
|
| 164 | Pinhead strongman | Bertram | 17%
|
| 167 | Lemoyne pig farmer | Bray Aberdeen | 17%
|
| 44 | Valentine sheriff | Curtis Malloy | 17%
|
| 179 | Celebrity fisherman | Jeremy Gill | 17%
|
| 135 | U.S. Infantry captain | Lyndon Monroe | 17%
|
| 168 | Sister and lover of #167 | Tammy Aberdeen | 17%
|
| 172 | Philosophical writer | Evelyn Miller | 16%
|
| 134 | U.S. Infantry colonel | Henry Favours | 16%
|
| 117 | Right-hand man to #116 | Levi Simon | 16%
|
| 89 | Saint Denis painter | Charles Châtenay | 15%
|
| 182 | Cross-dressing lion tamer | Margaret | 15%
|
| 86 | Saint Denis nun | Sister Calderón | 15%
|
| 218 | Debtor | Chick Matthews | 14%
|
| 173 | Possible time traveller | Francis Sinclair | 14%
|
| 84 | Father of #82 and #83 | Mr. Gillis | 14%
|
| 222 | Debtor | Wróbel | 14%
|
| 47 | Blind fortune teller | Blind Man Cassidy | 13%
|
| 71 | Rhodes horse fence | Clay Davies | 13%
|
| 72 | Brother of #71 | Clive Davies | 13%
|
| 226 | Debtor | Lilly Millet | 12%
|
| 73 | Rhodes clerk | Alden Carruthers | 11%
|
| 111 | Butler of #110 | Jean-Marc Mercier | 11%
|
| 150 | Tumbleweed sheriff | Samuel Freeman | 11%
|
| 203 | Bounty target | Elias Green | 10%
|
| 35 | Pinkerton agent | Johns | 10%
|
| 185 | Lonely Englishman | Nigel | 10%
|
| 213 | Bounty target | Otis Skinner | 10%
|
| 198 | Gunslinger | Slim Grant | 10%
|
| 140 | Pronghorn Ranch foreman | Tom Dickens | 10%
|
| 201 | Bounty target | Benedict Allbright | 9%
|
| 171 | Unstable serial killer | Edmund Lowry Jr. | 9%
|
| 178 | Former slave catcher | Jeremiah Compson | 9%
|
| 114 | Lagras boatman | Jules | 9%
|
| 223 | Debtor | Mrs. Londonderry | 9%
|
| 87 | Saint Denis milliner | Algernon Wasp | 8%
|
| 51 | Son of #50 | Bob Crawford Jr. | 8%
|
| 50 | Cousin by marriage of #49 | Bob Crawford Sr. | 8%
|
| 148 | Armadillo shopkeeper | Herbert Moon | 8%
|
| 208 | Bounty target | Joshua Brown | 8%
|
| 119 | Guarma revolutionary | Leon Fuentes | 8%
|
| 125 | Sisika prison guard | Milliken | 8%
|
| 224 | Debtor | Algie Davison | 7%
|
| 38 | Valentine prostitute | Anastasia | 7%
|
| 123 | Balloonist | Arturo Bullard | 7%
|
| 227 | Love interest of #226 | Cooper | 7%
|
| 158 | Son of #157 | Edgar Watson | 7%
|
| 159 | Son of #157 | Elijah Watson | 7%
|
| 205 | Bounty target | Esteban Cortez | 7%
|
| 160 | Son of #157 | Ethan Watson | 7%
|
| 161 | Son of #157 | Ezra Watson | 7%
|
| 54 | Strawberry clerk | Hector Barlow | 7%
|
| 154 | Love interest of #152 and #153 | Helen | 7%
|
| 157 | Big Valley matriarch | Mama Watson | 7%
|
| 163 | Freakshow leader | Marjorie | 7%
|
| 210 | Bounty target | Mark Johnson | 7%
|
| 130 | Murfree Brood hostage | Meredith Buckley | 7%
|
| 225 | Son of #224 | Nate Davison | 7%
|
| 214 | Bounty target | Ramón Cortez | 7%
|
| 192 | Biographer and dime novelist | Theodore Levin | 7%
|
| 120 | Guarma revolutionary | Baptiste | 6%
|
| 170 | Paleontologist | Deborah MacGuiness | 6%
|
| 122 | Guarma guide | Gloria | 6%
|
| 78 | Henchman of #77 | Guido Martelli | 6%
|
| 124 | Sisika warden | Heston Jameson | 6%
|
| 220 | Debtor | J. John Weathers | 6%
|
| 126 | Annesburg sheriff | Jones | 6%
|
| 180 | Butcher Creek elder | Obediah Hinton | 6%
|
| 221 | Debtor | Winton Holmes | 6%
|
| 152 | East Coast socialite | Acrisius | 5%
|
| 147 | Pre-cut house seller | Albert Cakes | 5%
|
| 70 | Rhodes outlaw | Anders Anderson | 5%
|
| 75 | German immigrant | Andreas | 5%
|
| 32 | Pinkerton agent | Archer Fordham | 5%
|
| 219 | Debtor | Gwyn Hughes | 5%
|
| 209 | Bounty target | Lindsey Wofford | 5%
|
| 212 | Bounty target | Nathan Kirk | 5%
|
| 69 | Rhodes suffragette | Olive Calhoon | 5%
|
| 186 | Cigarette card collector | Phineas T. Ramsbottom | 5%
|
| 153 | Brother of #152 | Proetus | 5%
|
| 33 | Pinkerton agent | Danbury | 4%
|
| 131 | Mother of #130 | Etta Buckley | 4%
|
| 190 | Bounty hunter | James Langton | 4%
|
| 207 | Bounty target | Joaquin Arroyo | 4%
|
| 36 | Pinkerton agent | Orly | 4%
|
| 146 | Blackwater police chief | Oswald Dunbar | 4%
|
| 183 | Assistant to #182 | Sally Nash | 4%
|
| 145 | Blackwater gun-for-hire | Willard Wayne | 4%
|
| 155 | Supernatural being | Agnes Dowd | 3%
|
| 90 | Saint Denis theater host | Aldridge T. Abbington | 3%
|
| 162 | African-American doctor | Alphonse Renaud | 3%
|
| 142 | Blackwater banker | Ansel Atherton | 3%
|
| 97 | Saint Denis police chief | Benjamin Lambert | 3%
|
| 34 | Pinkerton agent | Bunter | 3%
|
| 76 | Opera singer | Chester Damsen | 3%
|
| 102 | Saint Denis hosiery king | Desmond Blythe | 3%
|
| 144 | Blackwater gun-for-hire | Devon | 3%
|
| 175 | Demented veteran | Hayden Russell | 3%
|
| 176 | One-legged veteran | Joe Butler | 3%
|
| 181 | Butcher Creek resident | Lemuel | 3%
|
| 105 | Saint Denis socialite | Lillian Powell | 3%
|
| 48 | Flatneck Station poker player | Luther | 3%
|
| 127 | Annesburg scientist | Malcolm MacIntosh | 3%
|
| 211 | Bounty target | Marshall Thurwell | 3%
|
| 184 | Latin-American explorer | Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino | 3%
|
| 189 | Husband of #17 | Pierre | 3%
|
| 215 | Bounty target | Robbie Laidlaw | 3%
|
| 94 | Saint Denis singer | Robin Koninsky | 3%
|
| 216 | Bounty target | Shane Finley | 3%
|
| 112 | New Haven art critic | Shiftacre | 3%
|
| 53 | Strawberry sheriff (1907) | Vernon Farley | 3%
|
| 96 | Saint Denis loan shark | Ashton | 2%
|
| 200 | Bounty target | Bart Cavanaugh | 2%
|
| 92 | Saint Denis magician | Benjamin Lazarus | 2%
|
| 74 | Lemoyne Raiders moonshiner | Billy Lime | 2%
|
| 202 | Bounty target | Camille de Millemont | 2%
|
| 129 | Annesburg union representative | Didsbury | 2%
|
| 99 | Saint Denis suffragette | Dorothea Wicklow | 2%
|
| 52 | Strawberry sheriff (1899) | Hanley | 2%
|
| 95 | Saint Denis newspaperman | Hector Fellows | 2%
|
| 206 | Bounty target | Herman Zizendorf | 2%
|
| 29 | Assistant to #28 | Jansen | 2%
|
| 103 | Saint Denis doctor | Joseph R. Barnes | 2%
|
| 45 | Love interest of #44 | Moira Calthorpe | 2%
|
| 149 | Armadillo sheriff | Palmer | 2%
|
| 42 | Valentine gunsmith | R.L. Dalton | 2%
|
| 217 | Bounty target | Wilson J. McDaniels | 2%
|
| 91 | Saint Denis fire breather | Antoinette Sanseverino | 1%
|
| 143 | Blackwater photographer | Benjamin P. Lockhart | 1%
|
| 191 | Worshiper of the Sun | Bob Brownlee | 1%
|
| 108 | Saint Denis upper class woman | Camilla McClair | 1%
|
| 128 | Annesburg mine foreman | Dockery | 1%
|
| 109 | Saint Denis businessman | Hobart Crawley | 1%
|
| 93 | Saint Denis strongwoman | Hortensia | 1%
|
| 166 | Van Horn barkeeper | Josie Dawson | 1%
|
| 106 | Saint Denis art connoiseur | Mabel | 1%
|
| 41 | Valentine auctioneer | Morris Peyton | 1%
|
| 55 | Strawberry mayor | Nicholas Timmins | 1%
|
| 100 | Saint Denis eugenics promoter | Norris Forsythe | 1%
|
| 132 | Railroad Camp foreman | Percy Whitsickle | 1%
|
| 56 | Strawberry preacher | Peter Fotheringham | 1%
|
| 151 | Tumbleweed gunsmith | Roscoe Brenner | 1%
|
| 101 | Saint Denis con artist | Timothy A. Donahue | 1%
|
| 104 | Saint Denis photographer | Marcel Beliveau | 0%
|
| 107 | Saint Denis shopkeeper | Ruprecht O'Keith | 0%
|