| N | Position | Player | Caps (pre world cup) | Caps (all-time) | Club | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | FW | Robbie Keane | 33 | 146 | Leeds United | 97%
|
| 6 | MF | Roy Keane | 58 | 67 | Manchester United | 97%
|
| 1 | GK | Shay Given | 39 | 134 | Newcastle United | 97%
|
| 9 | MF | Damien Duff | 26 | 100 | Blackburn Rovers | 90%
|
| 17 | FW | Niall Quinn | 88 | 92 | Sunderland | 79%
|
| 5 | DF | Steve Staunton | 98 | 102 | Aston Villa | 76%
|
| 3 | DF | Ian Harte | 40 | 64 | Leeds United | 72%
|
| 2 | DF | Steve Finnan | 13 | 53 | Fulham | 72%
|
| 11 | MF | Kevin Kilbane | 31 | 110 | Sunderland | 69%
|
| 15 | DF | Richard Dunne | 14 | 80 | Manchester City | 69%
|
| 23 | GK | Alan Kelly | 34 | 34 | Blackburn Rovers | 66%
|
| 14 | DF | Gary Breen | 43 | 63 | Coventry City | 66%
|
| 18 | DF | Gary Kelly | 46 | 52 | Leeds United | 66%
|
| 8 | MF | Matt Hollan | 19 | 49 | Ipswich Town | 66%
|
| 19 | FW | Clinton Morrison | 7 | 36 | Crystal Palace | 59%
|
| 16 | GK | Dean Kiely | 6 | 11 | Charlton Athletic | 59%
|
| 7 | MF | Jason McAteer | 47 | 52 | Sunderland | 59%
|
| 4 | DF | Kenny Cunningham | 38 | 72 | Wimbledon | 59%
|
| 22 | MF | Lee Carsley | 19 | 40 | Everton | 52%
|
| 12 | MF | Mark Kinsella | 28 | 48 | Charlton Athletic | 48%
|
| 21 | MF | Steven Reid | 5 | 23 | Millwall | 48%
|
| 20 | DF | Andrew O'Brien | 5 | 26 | Newcastle United | 41%
|
| 13 | FW | David Connolly | 33 | 41 | Wimbledon | 41%
|