| Heartbreak | Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Super Bowl XLIII 27-23 loss to Pittsburgh Steelers (2008) | Arizona Cardinals | 100%
|
| Super Bowl LI 34-28 loss to New England Patriots (2016) | Atlanta Falcons | 100%
|
| AFC Championship 23-20 loss to New England Patriots (2011) | Baltimore Ravens | 97%
|
| Super Bowl XXV 20-19 loss to New York Giants (1990) | Buffalo Bills | 97%
|
| Super Bowl 50 24-10 loss to Denver Broncos (2015) | Carolina Panthers | 97%
|
| NFC Wild Card 16-15 loss to Philadelphia Eagles (2018) | Chicago Bears | 97%
|
| AFC Championship 37-31 loss to New England Patriots (2018) | Kansas City Chiefs | 97%
|
| Super Bowl XLIX 28-24 loss to New England Patriots (2014) | Seattle Seahawks | 97%
|
| NFC Divisional Round 34-31 loss to Green Bay Packers (2016) | Dallas Cowboys | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XLVIII 43-8 loss to Seattle Seahawks (2013) | Denver Broncos | 93%
|
| NFC Championship 28-22 loss to Seattle Seahawks (2014) | Green Bay Packers | 93%
|
| AFC Divisional Round 51-31 loss to Kansas City Chiefs (2019) | Houston Texans | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XLIV 31-17 loss to New Orleans Saints (2009) | Indianapolis Colts | 93%
|
| AFC Championship 24-20 loss to New England Patriots (2017) | Jacksonville Jaguars | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XXXVII 48-21 loss to Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2002) | Las Vegas Raiders | 93%
|
| AFC Divisional Round 41-28 loss to New England Patriots (2018) | Los Angeles Chargers | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XXXVI 20-17 loss to New England Patriots (2001) | Los Angeles Rams | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XIX 38-18 loss to San Francisco 49ers (1984) | Miami Dolphins | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XLII 17-14 loss to New York Giants (2007) | New England Patriots | 93%
|
| NFC Championship 26-23 loss to Los Angeles Rams (2018) | New Orleans Saints | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XXXV 34-7 loss to Baltimore Ravens (2000) | New York Giants | 93%
|
| AFC Championship 24-19 loss to Pittsburgh Steelers (2010) | New York Jets | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XXXIX 24-21 loss to New England Patriots (2004) | Philadelphia Eagles | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XLV 31-25 loss to Green Bay Packers (2010) | Pittsburgh Steelers | 93%
|
| Super Bowl LIV 31-20 loss to Kansas City Chiefs (2019) | San Francisco 49ers | 93%
|
| NFC Championship 11-6 loss to St Louis Rams (1999) | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 93%
|
| Super Bowl XXXIV 23-16 loss to St Louis Rams (1999) | Tennessee Titans | 93%
|
| AFC Divisional Round 22-17 loss to Kansas City Chiefs (2020) | Cleveland Browns | 90%
|
| NFC Wild Card 10-9 loss to Seattle Seahawks (2015) | Minnesota Vikings | 90%
|
| NFC Wild Card 24-14 loss to Seattle Seahawks | Washington Football Team | 90%
|
| Super Bowl XXIII 20-16 loss to San Francisco 49ers (1988) | Cincinnati Bengals | 87%
|
| NFC Wild Card 24-20 loss to Dallas Cowboys (2014) | Detroit Lions | 87%
|