| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Patrick Harris | Count Olaf | 100%
|
| Louis Hynes | Klaus | 98%
|
| Malina Weissman | Violet | 98%
|
| Presley Smith | Sunny | 95%
|
| K. Todd Freeman | Mr. Poe | 87%
|
| Patrick Warburton | Lemony Snicket | 81%
|
| Lucy Punch | Esmé | 70%
|
| Usmann Alley | Fernald | Hooky | Hook-Handed Man | 54%
|
| Dylan Kingwell | Duncan | Quigley | 50%
|
| Avi Lake | Isadora | 48%
|
| Nathan Fillion | Jacques Snicket | 46%
|
| Joan Cusack | Justice Strauss | 44%
|
| Allison Williams | Kit Snicket | 44%
|
| Jacqueline Robbins and Joyce Robbins | White-Faced Women | 38%
|
| Aasif Mandvi | Dr. Montgomery Montgomery | 36%
|
| Kitana Turnbull | Carmelita Spats | 32%
|
| Tony Hale | Jerome | 26%
|
| Sara Rue | Olivia Caliban | Madame Lulu | 26%
|
| John DeSantis | Bald Man | 18%
|
| Patrick Breen | Larry Your-Waiter | 18%
|
| Matt Cardarople | Person of Indeterminate Gender | 18%
|
| Ithamar Enriquez | Hector | 10%
|