| Appearances | Duration | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 441 | 1998 – 2009 | Gareth Barry | 80%
|
| 391 | 2005 – 2018 | Gabriel Agbonlahor | 60%
|
| 454 | 1977 – 1996 | Nigel Spink | 40%
|
| 430 | 1945 – 1961 | Johnny Dixon | 20%
|
| 469 | 1977 – 1989 | Allan Evans | 0%
|
| 390 | 1919 – 1931 | Arthur Dorrell | 0%
|
| 401 | 1897 – 1911 | Billy George | 0%
|
| 531 | 1919 – 1933 | Billy Walker | 0%
|
| 660 | 1959 – 1976 | Charlie Aitken | 0%
|
| 405 | 1975 – 1985 | Dennis Mortimer | 0%
|
| 392 | 1927 – 1946 | Eric Houghton | 0%
|
| 528 | 1976 – 19851988 – 1991 1993 – 1994 | Gordon Cowans | 0%
|
| 376 | 1904 – 1920 | Harry Hampton | 0%
|
| 354 | 1889 – 1902 | James Cowan | 0%
|
| 474 | 1900 – 1914 | Joe Bache | 0%
|
| 390 | 1915 – 1931 | Richard York | 0%
|
| 350 | 1991 – 19982000 – 2003 | Steve Staunton | 0%
|
| 368 | 1921 – 1935 | Thomas Mort | 0%
|
| 452 | 1920 – 1934 | Tommy Smart | 0%
|
| 351 | 1951 – 1964 | Vic Crowe | 0%
|