| Appearances | Duration | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 458 | 2010 – 20132014 – 2023 | Wilfried Zaha | 100%
|
| 360 | 2012 – now | Joel Ward | 78%
|
| 293 | 1907 – 1919 | Joshua Johnson | 44%
|
| 405 | 2004 – 2019 | Julián Speroni | 33%
|
| 312 | 1997 – 20022005 – 2008 | Clinton Morrison | 22%
|
| 349 | 1989 – 1996 | Nigel Martyn | 22%
|
| 368 | 1995 – 19972000 – 2008 | Dougie Freedman | 11%
|
| 663 | 1972 – 1988 | Jim Cannon | 11%
|
| 388 | 1964 – 1974 | John Jackson | 11%
|
| 293 | 1976 – 1984 | Vince Hilaire | 11%
|
| 440 | 1921 – 1934 | Albert Harry | 0%
|
| 302 | 1925 – 1936 | Bill Turner | 0%
|
| 317 | 1921 – 1932 | Bob Greener | 0%
|
| 318 | 1964 – 1973 | David Payne | 0%
|
| 299 | 1925 – 1933 | George Clarke | 0%
|
| 293 | 1928 – 1938 | Jimmy Wilde | 0%
|
| 319 | 1974 – 1983 | Paul Hinshelwood | 0%
|
| 328 | 1990 – 2002 | Simon Rodger | 0%
|
| 295 | 1965 – 19711978 – 1980 | Steve Kember | 0%
|
| 480 | 1955 – 1969 | Terry Long | 0%
|