| Appearances | Duration | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 382 | 2015 – now | Kevin De Bruyne | 88%
|
| 390 | 2011 – 2021 | Sergio Agüero | 86%
|
| 436 | 2010 – 2020 | David Silva | 74%
|
| 383 | 2013 – 2022 | Fernandinho | 54%
|
| 501 | 1966 – 1979 | Colin Bell | 38%
|
| 452 | 1965 – 1975 | Mike Summerbee | 30%
|
| 682 | 1959 – 1976 | Alan Oakes | 22%
|
| 603 | 1967 – 1983 | Joe Corrigan | 20%
|
| 570 | 1965 – 1978 | Mike Doyle | 18%
|
| 380 | 1962 – 1975 | Glyn Pardoe | 10%
|
| 416 | 1961 – 1971 | Neil Young | 10%
|
| 444 | 1975 – 1986 | Paul Power | 10%
|
| 545 | 1949 – 1964 | Bert Trautmann | 8%
|
| 393 | 1894 – 19051921 – 1924 | Billy Meredith | 8%
|
| 493 | 1928 – 1939 | Eric Brook | 8%
|
| 491 | 1968 – 1981 | Tommy Booth | 8%
|
| 436 | 1970 – 1980 | Willie Donachie | 6%
|
| 382 | 1986 – 1998 | Ian Brightwell | 4%
|
| 407 | 1924 – 1935 | Sam Cowan | 2%
|
| 411 | 1929 – 1939 | Ernie Toseland | 0%
|