| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Main Protagonist | Arthur Morgan | 99%
|
| Secondary Protagonist | John Marston | 98%
|
| Leader of the Gang | Dutch van der Linde | 96%
|
| Son of Abigail Roberts | Jack Marston | 93%
|
| Wife of John Marston | Abigail Roberts | 91%
|
| Dishonorably discharged from the military service for attempted murder and deviancy | Bill Williamson | 88%
|
| Born to an African American father and a native American mother | Charles Smith | 88%
|
| Joined the gang after fleeing Mexico after killing a high-ranking army official | Javier Escuella | 87%
|
| Co-Found and Second in Command | Hosea Matthews | 86%
|
| Primary Antagonist | Micah Bell | 84%
|
| Gang saves her from O'Driscolls | Sadie Adler | 83%
|
| Cook and Butcher | Mr. Pearson | 80%
|
| Old person who suffers from terminal lumbago | Uncle | 80%
|
| Dutch's lover | Molly O'Shea | 77%
|
| Captured O'Driscoll | Kieran Duffy | 76%
|
| Son of Rains Falls | Eagle Flies | 75%
|
| Leader of Rival Gang | Colm O'Driscoll | 74%
|
| Bookkeeper and Accountant | Leopold Strauss | 74%
|
| Leader Detective of the Pinkerton Detective Agency | Andrew Milton | 73%
|
| Wealthy Italian businessman and crimial from Saint Denis | Angelo Bronte | 73%
|
| The two rival families in Rhodes | Gray & Braithwaite | 73%
|
| After his father was shot, he shot his father's killers and ran away and found the gang | Lenny Summers | 73%
|
| Priest | Reverend Swanson | 73%
|
| Flamboyant Conman | Josiah Trelawny | 70%
|
| Irish Thief | Sean MacGuire | 70%
|
| Wealthy man responsible for several businesses | Leviticus Cornwall | 69%
|
| The Handmaid | Tilly Jackson | 66%
|
| The chieftain of the Wapiti Indians | Rains Falls | 65%
|
| Helped orchestrate and participate in the robbery of the Valentine Bank | Karen Jones | 64%
|
| The Arbiter | Susan Grimshaw | 63%
|
| Governor of Caribbean Island Guarma | Alberto Fussar | 55%
|
| She assists Arthur on some occasions, including finding a lead on a train robbery | Mary Beth Gaskill | 54%
|