| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Whitey | Edward Ford | 100%
|
| Mr. October | Reggie Jackson | 100%
|
| Joltin' Joe | Joe DiMaggio | 97%
|
| Yogi | Lawrence Berra | 97%
|
| The Wizard of Oz | Ozzie Smith | 97%
|
| The Say Hey Kid | Willie Mays | 97%
|
| Hammerin' Hank | Hank Aaron | 94%
|
| Catfish | Jim Hunter | 94%
|
| Stan the Man | Stan Musial | 94%
|
| Mr. Cub | Ernie Banks | 91%
|
| Sparky | George Anderson | 91%
|
| Satchel | Leroy Page | 91%
|
| Goose | Rich Gossage | 91%
|
| Charlie Hustle | Pete Rose | 88%
|
| Oil Can | Dennis Boyd | 85%
|
| Pee Wee | Harold Reese | 85%
|
| Duke | Edwin Snider | 82%
|
| Hawk | Andre Dawson | 76%
|
| Pudge | Carlton Fisk | 76%
|
| Killer | Harmon Killebrew | 74%
|
| Boog | John Powell | 71%
|
| The Left Arm of God | Sandy Koufax | 71%
|
| Spaceman | Bill Lee | 68%
|
| The Splendid Splinter | Ted Williams | 68%
|
| The Commerce Comet | Mickey Mantle | 65%
|
| The Bird | Mark Fidrych | 62%
|
| Cookie | Octavio Rojas | 59%
|
| Scooter | Phil Rizzuto | 59%
|
| The Human Vacuum Cleaner | Brooks Robinson | 56%
|
| The Cobra | Dave Parker | 50%
|
| The Penguin | Ron Cey | 47%
|
| The Bull | Greg Luzinski | 44%
|
| The Human Rain Delay | Mike Hargrove | 29%
|
| The Blade | Mark Belanger | 26%
|
| Cakes | Jim Palmer | 21%
|