| Hint | # Ep. | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheerleader, witch, rat | 8 | Amy Madison | 100%
|
| Vampire king, entombed beneath Sunnydale for 60 years | 8 | The Master | 96%
|
| Buffy and Faith's new watcher | 9 | Wesley Wyndam-Pryce | 89%
|
| Peaceful, loose-skinned demon | 8 | Clem | 80%
|
| Angel's sire and longtime lover | 5 | Darla | 80%
|
| Buffy's college professor and leader of the Initiative | 9 | Maggie Walsh | 80%
|
| Misogynistic preacher | 5 | Caleb | 72%
|
| Vampire subordinate of Kakistos, later the Mayor | 5 | Mr. Trick | 61%
|
| Associate of Anya and vengeance demon | 7 | Halfrek | 54%
|
| College student who has a one-night stand with Buffy | 5 | Parker Abrams | 54%
|
| Led Buffy to the vampire king's lair, as foretold by Aurelius | 6 | The Anointed One | 52%
|
| Bully and football player who comes out as gay with Xander's help | 7 | Larry Blaisdell | 48%
|
| Owner of a demon bar, often beaten up for information | 5 | Willy the Snitch | 48%
|
| Lead singer of Dingoes Ate My Baby and Cordy's ex | 8 | Devon MacLeish | 37%
|
| Potential Slayer and leader of the Chicago squad | 8 | Rona | 33%
|
| Potential Slayer who didn't speak any English, only Cantonese | 6 | Chao-Ahn | 30%
|
| The first of the Potential Slayers to actually slay a vampire | 5 | Molly | 30%
|
| Potential Slayer and leader of the New York squad | 8 | Violet | 28%
|
| Glory's minions | 6 | Jinx | 20%
|
| Glory's minions | 6 | Murk | 15%
|