| Description | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The main 'elf', who snuck into Santa's sack at an orphanage and was raised in the North Pole | Buddy | 98%
|
| Wise old man at the North Pole who delivers presents on Christmas | Santa Claus | 98%
|
| The elf who raised the main elf, and tells the story | Papa Elf | 84%
|
| The main elf's real father who he set out to find, and who is on the naughty list | Walter Hobbs | 84%
|
| The son of above and the main elf's brother | Michael Hobbs | 71%
|
| The lady working at Gimbel's who the main elf develops a crush on | Jovie | 69%
|
| The main elf's real mother who passed away and never met him | Susan Wells | 65%
|
| The current wife of the main elf's father | Emily Hobbs | 43%
|
| The short children's book author who the main elf's father invites to his office | Miles Finch | 43%
|
| The snowman who encourages the main elf to find his father | Leon | 41%
|
| Receptionist at the main elf's father's office | Deb | 39%
|
| News lady for New York 1 | Charlotte Denin | 29%
|
| Doctor who determines the main elf to indeed be the son of his father | Dr. Leonardo | 10%
|
| Coworker #2 of the main elf's father | Eugene | 6%
|
| Coworker #1 of the main elf's father | Morris | 6%
|