| Hint | Contestants | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| “I’m just filling in for eraser.” | Pen | 99%
|
| “We have to stick together!” | Pin | 99%
|
| “You are NOT allowed in Dream Island, Leafy!” | Firey | 98%
|
| “Your so easy to SLAP!” | Coiny | 97%
|
| “Bossy Bot” | Golf Ball | 97%
|
| “There’s a whole world out there to enjoy, so, Enjoy it!” | Leafy | 97%
|
| “Oh noyo!” Bonus hint- “Yoylecake!” | Bubble | 96%
|
| “Bembership!” | Match | 96%
|
| “DON’T CALL ME NEEDY!!” | Needle | 96%
|
| “Activate the elimination prevention plan!” | Pencil | 96%
|
| “Buleh” | Rocky | 96%
|
| “But what is the next contest?” | Eraser | 95%
|
| “Aw, Seriously?” | David | 94%
|
| “I’m wearing non-slip shoes, so HA!” | Flower | 94%
|
| … | Teardrop | 94%
|
| “But I’m, like, the star of the show!” | Blocky | 93%
|
| “WALL TELEPORTER!” | Tennis Ball | 92%
|
| “You WEAKLING!” | Snowball | 89%
|
| “AHHHhH!” | Woody | 89%
|
| “Pencil!” | Ice Cube | 85%
|
| “Uh, uhhhh” | Spongy | 84%
|