| Area (km²) | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 105,806 | Cuba | 98%
|
| 73,929 | Hispaniola | 95%
|
| 4,827 | Trinidad | 95%
|
| 180 | Aruba | 93%
|
| 431 | Barbados | 93%
|
| 310 | Grenada | 93%
|
| 11,188 | Jamaica | 93%
|
| 168 | Saint Kitts | 93%
|
| 444 | Curaçao | 91%
|
| 300 | Tobago | 91%
|
| 1,128 | Martinique | 89%
|
| 8,896 | Puerto Rico | 89%
|
| 616 | Saint Lucia | 89%
|
| 345 | Saint Vincent | 89%
|
| 279 | Antigua | 86%
|
| 750 | Dominica | 86%
|
| 93 | Nevis | 86%
|
| 294 | Bonaire | 82%
|
| 87 | Saint Martin | 82%
|
| 161 | Barbuda | 80%
|
| 102 | Montserrat | 73%
|
| 91 | Anguilla | 70%
|
| 196 | Grand Cayman | 59%
|
| 21 | Saint Barthélemy | 57%
|
| 1,020 | Isla Margarita | 45%
|
| 214 | Saint Croix | 45%
|
| 81 | Saint Thomas | 45%
|
| 647 | Cozumel | 43%
|
| 13 | Saba | 43%
|
| 848 | Basse-Terre | 41%
|
| 51 | Saint John | 41%
|
| 2,237 | Isla de la Juventud | 39%
|
| 14 | Key West | 36%
|
| 21 | Sint Eustatius | 36%
|
| 56 | Tortola | 32%
|
| 157 | La Tortuga Island | 30%
|
| 587 | Grande-Terre | 27%
|
| 125 | Roatan | 27%
|
| 178 | Tortuga | 27%
|
| 135 | Vieques | 25%
|
| 26 | San Andrés | 23%
|
| 743 | Gonâve | 20%
|
| 158 | Marie Galante | 18%
|
| 57 | Isla Mona | 16%
|
| 26 | Little Cayman | 16%
|
| 17 | Providencia | 16%
|
| 38 | Cayo Largo del Sur | 14%
|
| 777 | Cayo Romano | 14%
|
| 21 | Virgin Gorda | 14%
|
| 38 | Anegada | 11%
|
| 34 | Carriacou | 11%
|
| 30 | Culebra | 11%
|
| 8 | Isleta de San Juan | 11%
|
| 110 | Saona Island | 11%
|
| 18 | Bequia | 9%
|
| 370 | Cayo Coco | 9%
|
| 37 | Cristóbal Island | 9%
|
| 8 | Jost Van Dyke | 9%
|
| 10 | Big Corn Island | 7%
|
| 64 | Blanquilla Island | 7%
|
| 13 | Canouan | 7%
|
| 10 | Catalina Island | 7%
|
| 36 | Cayman Brac | 7%
|
| 15 | Cayo Grande | 7%
|
| 24 | Cubagua | 7%
|
| 8 | Ronde Island | 7%
|
| 8 | Union Island | 7%
|
| 49 | Útila | 7%
|
| 65 | Ambergris Caye | 5%
|
| 52 | Bastimentos Island | 5%
|
| 27 | Beata Island | 5%
|
| 26 | Big Pine Key | 5%
|
| 16 | Cayo Agua Island | 5%
|
| 335 | Cayo Sabinal | 5%
|
| 55 | Coche Island | 5%
|
| 61 | Colón Island | 5%
|
| 55 | Guanaja | 5%
|
| 21 | La Désirade | 5%
|
| 40 | La Orchila | 5%
|
| 53 | Popa Island | 5%
|
| 8 | Solarte Island | 5%
|
| 26 | Cayo Cruz | 2%
|
| 101 | Cayo Fragoso | 2%
|
| 13 | Cayo Guillermo | 2%
|
| 42 | Cayo Saetia | 2%
|
| 45 | Grande Cayemite | 2%
|
| 32 | Great Harbour Cay | 2%
|
| 52 | Île à Vache | 2%
|
| 9 | Terre-de-Bas | 2%
|
| 20 | Tierra Bomba Island | 2%
|