England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland aren't technically countries (depsite the fact that every Englishman says England is a country, every Scotsman says Scotland is country, every Welshman says Wales is a country and every Northern Irishman says Northern Ireland is a country). England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland do not have seperate seats at the UN for example we are all part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Please stop pretending that Scotland is being somehow victimised! Have a good day.
"Scotland isn't a country, it's a kingdom...which is why they're in the United KINGDOM" would make a lot more sense if the name of the country were the United Kingdoms.
Scotland is what is known as a Constituent Country, specifically of the UK. Constituent Countries are basically Countries within a main country, and they are not Sovereign. Since Scotland is a Constituent, it is not Sovereign (independence/separatist movements do not count as Sovereign either). Scotland is a Constituent of the UK along with England, Wales, and Northern Ireland*. Other examples include: Greenland, Faroe Islands, and Denmark Proper to The Kingdom of Denmark; Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten, and Metropolitan Netherlands to the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Also note that not all Federations (like the UAE or the USA) have Constituents; Only the three listed (UK, Netherlands, Denmark) are officially made of Constituents. There's also the fact that JetPunk does not recognize Scotland as a nation. So with that, have a Nice/Good Day :)
*Please Fact Check me On Northern Ireland; I can't remember if it is a Constituent or not :(
The U.K was a union between England and Scotland, that's our baseline; I don't think anyone here would consider Scotland Annexed by It though, since the UK was not a state before Scotland. But you could make an interesting arguement for saying that England annexed Scotland, a bit like how Russia annexed/unified Poland after the Napoleonic wars.
Or even that Scotland annexed England, as James IV of Scotland inherited the throne of England (becoming James I there) to united the kingdoms. Of course, he reigned from London after inheriting the English throne and England was always the larger and more populous nation so it's a huge stretch to call the combined nation "Scotland".
The union of Scotland and England created Great Britain The UK was created with the addition of Ireland, later reduced to Northern Ireland.
The union came about because the Scottish King inherited the English throne (James VI/I). The governments and monarchies were later officially combined in 1701 under Queen Anne.
There was then continual violent imposition of control of the government from London. It wasn't necessarily a happy union for all the people, but it wasn't an annexation of one country by another.
I don't really see Z***e fitting here. How is it different from adding Swaziland if eSwatini changed its flag? I mean, is there anything besides a name change?
Borders Don't have to change for a new country to be formed. I mean, sure, it's not like the Culture changed or anything; it's essentially the same nation. You wouldn't say the French Empire wasn't France because it was an empire and not a kingdom/Republic, but in actuality, I doubt you would say any of those three iterations of France operate like the same country, would you? Just some food for thought
Nice quiz! A quick question, what's the difference between Zaire and DRC? I thought that Zaire was renamed to DRC but here Zaire is shown as a former country.
(I am not pointing out that it should be changed but I genuinely want to know)
Zaire was under the leadership of Joseph Mobutu, also known as Mobutu Sese Seko, after a coup d'etat in 1965, and he sought to Africanize the country, forcing citizens to change their names to more traditional African names. So basically, Zaire was a dictatorship under Seko until it eventually fell in 1997 and renamed back to the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Some of these flags are really cool, especially Tibet. Most of the shapes I was familiar with, but there were a few I had to zoom in and look at more closely.
Fun quiz! I agree, though, that I wouldn't call Zaire a "former country." It just changed its name and flag. Burma, for example, isn't a "former country."
Scotland is a country - one of four that makes up the United Kingdom/ Britain. The flag still exists and remains valid. Scots person here - don't want to get into a debate but it's very much a country in its own right. As are our neighbours, England, Northern Ireland and Wales.
I would really like to know who it is that keeps insisting that "Scotland is a country". I suspect that it's not Scottish people, who very likely know better than that. Maybe disgruntled Brits who fear for the future of the United Kingdom? Or just assorted nit-pickers from around the world who happen to all be wrong?
There could be an argument that Scotland is a "constituent country", if you agree that this is not the same thing as being a "country" (which is what this quiz is about).
If there is a requirement to be undisputed, then Israel isn't a country. Texas should definitely qualify. It had control of its territory, foreign relations with several large states, and was recognized as an independent nation by a few major powers.
Vermont is trickier, but I would still say they qualify as independent as they were definitely a sovereign state, and they had full control of their territory.
What I will say is that I think Texas's borders should be reduced to what they actually controlled, which was a much smaller part entirely within Texas's modern borders.
One could argue that a country is actual when it’s recognized by the one that’s ceding the territory. Israel’s territory was ceded by UK, who had the mandate of Palestine, and that’s why Israel has a seat at the United Nations. Mexico didn’t recognize the Republic of Texas, the territory was transfered to USA after the Mexican-American war.
I think that Texas was a “country” for 10 years during the 19th century as much as Crimea was a “country” for a couple of days in 2014: both had control of its territories and were recognized by a major power. But the end-game for both so-called republics was to be annexed by the big neighbor next door.
I think it's a bit more complex than just saying that if the country ceding the territory doesn't recognize it then it's not a country. For example Japan ceded the territory that is now North Korea after WW2 and it currently doesn't recognize North Korea. Not only that but it is likely that at some point in the future North Korea will no longer continue to exist. Despite that I think we can all agree that North Korea is, unfortunately for everyone but the Kims, an independent country.
It's a "country of the UK", which is not a country in the internationally accepted sense of the word which is oh! so clearly! used in this quiz. The word "country" translates to "Land" in German - would you argue that Bavaria and the Saarland are countries? Is "Flavour Country" a country ? Is "Country Kitchen Buffet"?
the Austria-Hungary flag is wrong. Austria-Hungary did not have a single national flag as it was two nations bound together by a monarchy. the flag commonly (and incorrectly) used is the civil ensign. this is because sometime in 2003 someone on wikipedia made that the flag and it has since spread across the web.
That is not the flag of Austria-Hungary, nor was it ever the flag of Austria-Hungary. Also, calling the HRE a country is a pretty big stretch. That would be like calling the European Union a country
Calling Austria-Hungary a country is a bit of a stretch in itself. Austria and Hungary were two different countries, just with the same monarch. Similar to, for example, the United Kingdoms of Sweden and Norway, or the position of Finland an Poland within the Russian Empire. Austria-Hungary had no single flag, just the flags of Austria and Hungary.
Eh. While it is true that Austria and Hungary had separate governments, currency, capitals, etcetera, they were also united on other fronts, like foreign policy and army. Austria-Hungary was more of a "Real Union" as opposed to say, Sweden-Norway or the Commonwealth Realms of nowadays, which are personal unions.
Scotland really is a seperate country within the UK
It's a part of the United Kingdom. Not an own country. Get your facts right, man.
*Please Fact Check me On Northern Ireland; I can't remember if it is a Constituent or not :(
The union came about because the Scottish King inherited the English throne (James VI/I). The governments and monarchies were later officially combined in 1701 under Queen Anne.
There was then continual violent imposition of control of the government from London. It wasn't necessarily a happy union for all the people, but it wasn't an annexation of one country by another.
(I am not pointing out that it should be changed but I genuinely want to know)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Democratic_Republic_of_the_Congo#:~:text=Mobutu%20remained%20the%20head%20of,Democratic%20Republic%20of%20the%20Congo.
CANNOT READ
THERES A WHOLE THREAD ABOUT SCOTLAND AT THE TOP
If an eastern Moldovan insisted that their country was "Transnistria", would we respect that in the same way? Or Chechnya, etc.
Having said that, we can use the term "country" a bit loosely, so there doesn't need to be a big debate about it.
Vermont is trickier, but I would still say they qualify as independent as they were definitely a sovereign state, and they had full control of their territory.
What I will say is that I think Texas's borders should be reduced to what they actually controlled, which was a much smaller part entirely within Texas's modern borders.
I think that Texas was a “country” for 10 years during the 19th century as much as Crimea was a “country” for a couple of days in 2014: both had control of its territories and were recognized by a major power. But the end-game for both so-called republics was to be annexed by the big neighbor next door.
https://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/1306568/geographical-shapes
Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, East Germany, South Vietnam and Zaire.
( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3ZOqyl1RBY )