| Category | # | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| One of the world's five largest islands – other than Greenland | 5 | Borneo | Madagascar | New Guinea | Baffin Island | Sumatra | 91%
|
| Population > 1 million and in the Mediterranean | 3 | Cyprus | Sardinia | Sicily | 78%
|
| Also the name of a European nation | 3 | Iceland | Ireland | Malta | 78%
|
| Has > 5 million native Chinese speakers | 2 | Hainan | Taiwan | 75%
|
| Where Napoleon lived | 3 | Corsica | Elba | Saint Helena | 73%
|
| Population > 1 million and in the 50 U.S. states | 2 | Long Island | Manhattan | 70%
|
| Has a population > 100 million | 2 | Honshu | Java | 67%
|
| One of the two main islands of New Zealand | 2 | North Island | South Island | 67%
|
| Has > 1 million native Spanish speakers | 3 | Cuba | Hispaniola | Puerto Rico | 64%
|
| Shared between multiple countries, and has a country capital | 5 | Borneo | Hispaniola | Ireland | New Guinea | Timor | 63%
|
| One of the five largest islands in the Caribbean named for a saint | 5 | Saint Lucia | Saint Vincent | Saint Croix | Saint Kitts | Saint Martin | 59%
|
| One of the main islands of Hawaii – other than Hawaii itself | 7 | Kahoolawe | Kauai | Lanai | Maui | Molokai | Niihau | Oahu | 57%
|
| One of the five largest islands of the Philippines | 5 | Luzon | Mindanao | Negros | Palawan | Samar | 48%
|
| An inhabited Balearic island | 4 | Formentera | Ibiza | Mallorca | Minorca | 47%
|
| One of Greece's five largest islands – other than Crete | 5 | Euboea | Lesbos | Rhodes | Chios | Kefalonia | 45%
|
| Is a British crown dependency | 3 | Guernsey | Isle of Man | Jersey | 45%
|
| One of Canada's three most populous islands | 3 | Montreal | Vancouver | Newfoundland | 45%
|
| One of the A.B.C. islands of the Caribbean | 3 | Aruba | Bonaire | Curacao | 39%
|
| One of Scotland's six largest islands | 6 | Lewis and Harris | Skye | Shetland | Mull | Islay | Mainland Orkney | 34%
|