| Rank | Answer | Active | Team (most games) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Johnny Bench | 1967-1983 | Cincinnati Reds | 93%
|
| 5 | Mike Piazza | 1992-2007 | New York Mets | 86%
|
| 1 | Yogi Berra | 1946-1965 | New York Yankees | 86%
|
| 13 | Ivan Rodriguez | 1991-2011 | Texas Rangers | 79%
|
| 14 | Thurman Munson | 1969-1979 | New York Yankees | 79%
|
| 6 | Carlton Fisk | 1969-1993 | Chicago White Sox | 71%
|
| 8 | Gary Carter | 1974-1992 | Montréal Expos | 71%
|
| 3 | Roy Campanella | 1948-1957 | Brooklyn Dodgers | 71%
|
| 7 | Bill Dickey | 1928-1946 | New York Yankees | 57%
|
| 22 | Ernie Lombardi | 1931-1947 | Cincinnati Reds | 57%
|
| 15 | Elston Howard | 1955-1968 | New York Yankees | 50%
|
| 19 | Lance Parrish | 1977-1995 | Detroit Tigers | 43%
|
| 42 | Manny Sanguillen | 1967-1980 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 43%
|
| 4 | Mickey Cochrane | 1925-1937 | Philadelphia Athletics | 43%
|
| 9 | Gabby Hartnett | 1922-1941 | Chicago Cubs | 36%
|
| 23 | Gene Tenace | 1969-1983 | Oakland Athletics | 36%
|
| 24 | Tim McCarver | 1959-1980 | St. Louis Cardinals | 36%
|
| 12 | Bill Freehan | 1961-1976 | Detroit Tigers | 29%
|
| 18 | Darrell Porter | 1971-1987 | Milwaukee Brewers | 29%
|
| 100 | Earl Smith | 1919-1930 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 29%
|
| 66 | Jerry Grote | 1963-1981 | New York Mets | 29%
|
| 90 | Jody Davis | 1981-1990 | Chicago Cubs | 29%
|
| 11 | Joe Torre | 1960-1977 | Atlanta Braves | 29%
|
| 35 | Ray Schalk | 1912-1929 | Chicago White Sox | 29%
|
| 43 | Rick Dempsey | 1969-1992 | Baltimore Orioles | 29%
|
| 71 | Spud Davis | 1928-1945 | Philadelphia Phillies | 29%
|
| 41 | Al Lopez | 1928-1947 | Brooklyn Dodgers | 21%
|
| 25 | Darren Daulton | 1983-1997 | Philadelphia Phillies | 21%
|
| 27 | John Roseboro | 1957-1970 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 21%
|
| 37 | Mickey Tettleton | 1984-1997 | Detroit Tigers | 21%
|
| 106 | Ray Fosse | 1967-1979 | Cleveland Indians | 21%
|
| 78 | Steve Yeager | 1972-1986 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 21%
|
| 10 | Ted Simmons | 1968-1988 | St. Louis Cardinals | 21%
|
| 34 | Tony Pena | 1980-1997 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 21%
|
| 116 | Art Wilson | 1908-1921 | Chicago Whales | 14%
|
| 21 | Bob Boone | 1972-1990 | Philadelphia Phillies | 14%
|
| 76 | Doggie Miller | 1884-1896 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 14%
|
| 95 | George Gibson | 1905-1918 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 14%
|
| 63 | Jimmie Wilson | 1923-1940 | Philadelphia Phillies | 14%
|
| 79 | Joe Ferguson | 1970-1983 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 14%
|
| 108 | Mike Heath | 1978-1991 | Oakland Athletics | 14%
|
| 36 | Mike Scioscia | 1980-1992 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 14%
|
| 109 | Randy Hundley | 1964-1977 | Chicago Cubs | 14%
|
| 16 | Roger Bresnahan | 1897-1915 | New York Giants | 14%
|
| 89 | Ron Hassey | 1978-1991 | Cleveland Indians | 14%
|
| 31 | Sherm Lollar | 1946-1963 | Chicago White Sox | 14%
|
| 38 | Terry Steinbach | 1986-1999 | Oakland Athletics | 14%
|
| 33 | Walker Cooper | 1940-1957 | St. Louis Cardinals | 14%
|
| 68 | Alan Ashby | 1973-1989 | Houston Astros | 7%
|
| 102 | Bob Brenly | 1981-1989 | San Francisco Giants | 7%
|
| 97 | Bo Diaz | 1977-1989 | Cincinnati Reds | 7%
|
| 17 | Buck Ewing | 1880-1897 | New York Giants | 7%
|
| 65 | Butch Wynegar | 1976-1988 | Minnesota Twins | 7%
|
| 96 | Charlie Moore | 1973-1987 | Milwaukee Brewers | 7%
|
| 30 | Del Crandall | 1949-1966 | Milwaukee Braves | 7%
|
| 67 | Don Slaught | 1982-1997 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 7%
|
| 50 | Earl Battey | 1955-1967 | Minnesota Twins | 7%
|
| 72 | Ernie Whitt | 1976-1991 | Toronto Blue Jays | 7%
|
| 56 | Gus Triandos | 1953-1965 | Baltimore Orioles | 7%
|
| 124 | Matt Nokes | 1985-1995 | New York Yankees | 7%
|
| 105 | Rich Gedman | 1980-1992 | Boston Red Sox | 7%
|
| 101 | Rick Cerone | 1975-1992 | New York Yankees | 7%
|
| 29 | Rick Ferrell | 1929-1947 | Washington Senators | 7%
|
| 119 | Ron Karkovice | 1986-1997 | Chicago White Sox | 7%
|
| 28 | Smoky Burgess | 1949-1967 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 7%
|
| 92 | Stan Lopata | 1948-1960 | Philadelphia Phillies | 7%
|
| 52 | Terry Kennedy | 1978-1991 | San Diego Padres | 7%
|
| 120 | Tom Pagnozzi | 1987-1998 | St. Louis Cardinals | 7%
|
| 57 | Andy Seminick | 1943-1957 | Philadelphia Phillies | 0%
|
| 98 | Babe Phelps | 1931-1942 | Brooklyn Dodgers | 0%
|
| 121 | Bill Killefer | 1909-1921 | Philadelphia Phillies | 0%
|
| 118 | Bill Rariden | 1909-1920 | Boston Braves | 0%
|
| 64 | Birdie Tebbetts | 1936-1952 | Detroit Tigers | 0%
|
| 46 | Bob O'Farrell | 1915-1935 | Chicago Cubs | 0%
|
| 99 | Brian Harper | 1979-1995 | Minnesota Twins | 0%
|
| 85 | Bubbles Hargrave | 1913-1930 | Cincinnati Reds | 0%
|
| 49 | Charlie Bennett | 1878-1893 | Detroit Wolverines | 0%
|
| 62 | Chief Zimmer | 1884-1903 | Cleveland Spiders | 0%
|
| 107 | Clay Dalrymple | 1960-1971 | Philadelphia Phillies | 0%
|
| 123 | Clint Courtney | 1951-1961 | Washington Senators | 0%
|
| 114 | Clyde McCullough | 1940-1956 | Chicago Cubs | 0%
|
| 113 | Cy Perkins | 1915-1934 | Philadelphia Athletics | 0%
|
| 40 | Deacon McGuire | 1884-1912 | Washington Senators | 0%
|
| 87 | Del Rice | 1945-1961 | St. Louis Cardinals | 0%
|
| 45 | Duke Farrell | 1888-1905 | Washington Senators | 0%
|
| 39 | Ed Bailey | 1953-1966 | Cincinnati Reds | 0%
|
| 75 | Frankie Hayes | 1933-1947 | Philadelphia Athletics | 0%
|
| 112 | Frankie Pytlak | 1932-1946 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 61 | Frank Snyder | 1912-1927 | St. Louis Cardinals | 0%
|
| 83 | Fred Carroll | 1884-1891 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 0%
|
| 74 | Gus Mancuso | 1928-1945 | New York Giants | 0%
|
| 77 | Hank Gowdy | 1910-1930 | Boston Braves | 0%
|
| 70 | Hank Severeid | 1911-1926 | St. Louis Browns | 0%
|
| 55 | Harry Danning | 1933-1942 | New York Giants | 0%
|
| 82 | Heinie Peitz | 1892-1913 | Cincinnati Reds | 0%
|
| 80 | Ivey Wingo | 1911-1929 | Cincinnati Reds | 0%
|
| 58 | Jack Clements | 1884-1900 | Philadelphia Phillies | 0%
|
| 60 | Jack Meyers | 1909-1917 | New York Giants | 0%
|
| 81 | Jack O'Connor | 1887-1910 | Cleveland Spiders | 0%
|
| 44 | Jim Hegan | 1941-1960 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 32 | Jim Sundberg | 1974-1989 | Texas Rangers | 0%
|
| 103 | Jocko Milligan | 1884-1893 | Philadelphia Athletics | 0%
|
| 117 | Joe Azcue | 1960-1972 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 47 | Johnny Bassler | 1913-1927 | Detroit Tigers | 0%
|
| 53 | Johnny Edwards | 1961-1974 | Cincinnati Reds | 0%
|
| 48 | Johnny Kling | 1900-1913 | Chicago Cubs | 0%
|
| 73 | John Romano | 1958-1967 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 115 | Lou Criger | 1896-1912 | Boston Red Sox | 0%
|
| 59 | Luke Sewell | 1921-1942 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 88 | Mickey Owen | 1937-1954 | Brooklyn Dodgers | 0%
|
| 122 | Mike Gonzalez | 1912-1932 | St. Louis Cardinals | 0%
|
| 91 | Mike LaValliere | 1984-1995 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 0%
|
| 84 | Mike Macfarlane | 1987-1999 | Kansas City Royals | 0%
|
| 125 | Mike Tresh | 1938-1949 | Chicago White Sox | 0%
|
| 51 | Muddy Ruel | 1915-1934 | Washington Senators | 0%
|
| 110 | Ossee Schrecongost | 1897-1908 | Philadelphia Athletics | 0%
|
| 93 | Phil Masi | 1939-1952 | Boston Braves | 0%
|
| 69 | Rollie Hemsley | 1928-1947 | St. Louis Browns | 0%
|
| 111 | Sammy White | 1951-1962 | Boston Red Sox | 0%
|
| 94 | Shanty Hogan | 1925-1937 | New York Giants | 0%
|
| 54 | Steve O'Neill | 1911-1928 | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 26 | Tom Haller | 1961-1972 | San Francisco Giants | 0%
|
| 20 | Wally Schang | 1913-1931 | Philadelphia Athletics | 0%
|
| 104 | Wes Westrum | 1947-1957 | New York Giants | 0%
|
| 86 | Wilbert Robinson | 1886-1902 | Baltimore Orioles | 0%
|